Reviews for Grumpy Jack's in Port Jefferson, NY
Diner BEWARE: at the very bottom of the menu in small print you will find: "Prices listed are based on a cash discount.....3.5... percent service fee is added to credit card..." Now on to the food: Notice in the picture the item in the upper left corner? Noit's not a paperweight. That compressed lump is the stuffing from my crab stuffed flounder. See the potato? It appears to be aregular white potato, but I ordered a sweet potato. Oh well, my mother taught me you don't always get what youwant............ On the other hand, the flounder was tasty and the green beans were outstanding. And the staff were all superpleasant. To sum it up: It is nice local hangout for a drink or appetizer, but I would take my dinner dining somewhere else.Also I don't patronize establishments that have "hidden fees" Read more
Super good. I had to try it a second time to see if it was as good as the first. IT WAS. The burgers are a good size, and cooked... perfectly how you like them. I got the french onion burger. It was amazing from the first until the last bite. Our waiters wereattentive, and super friendly. Great find. Read more
My fiancé and I tried this place and for a first impression they messed up his drink, too salty when he asked for sugar rim.... The price for it was up there. The fries were good, cocktail shrimp fine, his burger was good. Chicken wrap isn?t bad. Averageservice nice servers checked up. Read more
Great bar food , quick service nice drinks good prices and lots of offerings. Place is usually packed and can be quite loud.... Definitely will be back again! Read more
Delicious!! Great place to eat! We had a party of 6 and mostly everyone loved their food. Po Boys, Shrimp Risotto, and a Reuben... with Sweet Potato Fries. The Philly Omelette was not the best - wouldn?t recommend. The Fig Mule was so refreshing. Greatservice and great portions for the price. The atmosphere felt good. A local pub with a hospitable feel. We got our drinks andfood pretty fast. Definitely recommend! ???? Read more
We were a party of 4, no wait for dinner during the week. Had the codfish with bruschetta, kind of rustic looking inside. The... bar area always has a good crowd. They had used to have wing specials Tuesday nights, I don't know if that's still goingon. Anyway this is a good place for dinner or lunch with family or friends. Read more
Food is delicious if you're looking for pub fare or some comfort food. I left very full and satisfied. I had the burger special... with sweet potato fries and my friend had wings and fries. Both happy with our meals and had leftovers the next day :). Cleanbathroom, good service (we went in afternoon), and good prices. Recommend. Read more
This restaurant is more like an upscale "dive" bar. The menu has a lot of choices but a few of them missed the mark. Those of us... who ordered more traditional bar food were very happy. It was our first visit and we will be going back. Hopefully the foodquality will be better and we just caught them on an off night. Read more