Reviews for Gilshar Greek Cafe in Port Jefferson Station, NY

Came here for the first time today and it was absolutely amazing. Food was delicious and big portions for the price. Food tasted... fresh and home cooked. Our waitress, who seemed like the owner, was lovely and took good care of us. So much food we had to takeleftovers home. Definitely will be back for more!! Read more

I had great lemon chicken soup on a nippy night. You can really taste the lemon AND the seasoning is subtle, just right. Also,... they have whole wheat pita. The food is fresh, tasty and abundant. Nice people too! Read more

Lovely people and service. Ate a quick salad there last week. Choice came down to eating at Chipotle next door or supporting a... small business. Server (owner possibly) was very nice, made adjustments that I asked for, refilled m ice tea without asking andwas nice and polite. Read more

Been here several times. Always nice service and fast with chicken gyros (delicious). If waiting outside, they sometimes... bring it to you too. I'm looking forward to trying some of their other food! Read more

I came here Satuday to take my mom and family out for my mom's birthday. The staff is really great, professional, and friendly... with customers! The food is really great, and the prices are good. If you get Emma as a waitress, please include the 20% tip forher, she's really over above and beyond at what she does. Read more

My friend and I had a small Greek salad with grilled chicken, beef Gyro and spanakopita. The food was so fresh and so delicious.... We will definitely be back! Read more

Coming here around ten years, they recently started increasing prices, again, and when I ordered the hummus platter this is what... I got. Haven?t ordered again since, really disappointing. I?ve learned not to complain when they do something like this, becausethey always say they?ve been doing the same thing for years and nobody has ever complained. For any single issue I get this sameresponse, there was literally less than $0.25 of feta, and I PAID FOR EXTRA VEGETABLES - they gave me TWO maybe that could be 3OLIVES. I want my money back, but I wont argue with these owners over their mistakes, Read more

Best.grill chicken gyros I've had in a long time .The Greek salad was very delicious. The waitress was really nice and polite... small place about 9 or 10 tables but very cute place. Read more