Reviews for Margarita's Cafe Smithtown in Port Jefferson Station, NY

I thought we had found a neat new regular spot but I had a really bad experience here that made me never want to go back. Made a... reservation and when we were going to be seated we asked to sit at a slightly larger table, as to not be sandwiched and right ontop of other guests. The last time we were there the table didn’t fit the amount of food we ordered so we figured this wouldbe a simple request. But the man who was seating us was extraordinarily rude and said it wasn’t possible, even though therewere multiple tables available. Instead he said we could only sit at a table right at the front door. With below freezingtemperatures and the door swinging open and hitting the chair, this just wasn’t an option for us. He just could not even careless. Much rather go somewhere where your business is appreciated. Read more

Henry was awesome! $6 sangrias, tableside guacamole, great service, fajitas were excellent, steak quesadilla was so good! Steak... was tender and juicy. Will deff be back for Henry. Only complaint was the salsa was kinda weird. Read more

We thought it was a good idea to drop in, big mistake. Walked in during happy hour and when we got the bill we were charged... full price for every item on the happy hour menu. Spoke to waiter and manager, they came back with some corrections but not all,he even try to tell us the house tequila was patron. We can't be the first to get a bill like this, but double check your tab,I'm sure they doing this to other clientele as well Read more

The waitstaff was very friendly and helpful. 1st time here. Food was delicious! They had live music, which was really good too.... Acoustic Soul played. Really good band. No dancing, except the waitstaff. lol Not too loud, we were able to still talk. Read more

When our lunch was served, we suddenly remembered why we had not eaten here in a while. 1. We ordered crunchy tacos which were... sitting in the juices of the meat they were stuffed with. The shells were soggy and inedible. 2. Refried beans were smothered ingloopy cheese 3. The salsa is bland. 4. Lunch: pricey for what you get. On the positive side: Servers are very nice andfriendly and the meal comes quickly. Read more

it’s alright: food is mediocre, and drinks are expensive. music was way too loud for me. the bathrooms are gendered even... though they’re both the single stalls with no urinal. Read more

Energetic ambience...tasty food suitable for vegetarians...spicy enough. Tried fajitas, quesadillas and Pina Colada's were good!... Will come back again Read more

Besides the service being slooooow (we may have arrived after a big rush), the portions were large, food was really good... (recommend the steak burrito) and the prices are reasonable. The decor is great and the live music really makes the experiencemore fun. This place is still pretty new and I hope it makes it. Read more