Reviews for The Erie Hotel & Restaurant in Port Jervis, NY
We stopped in on our way home from New York today. I was here many years ago and it was good. Tonight it was awful. I never... write reviews unless they are terrible. Fried calamari and their attempt a marinara sauce sucked, French dip was OK, and theceasar salad was iceburg lettuce and croutons were like pebbles. The service was slow and it wasn't that crowded. Best thingthey served was this wierd bread but it was pretty good. It's was many years since I was there and we would not return. Honestlycould have been better satisfied at McDonald's. Read more
This review is only related to the hotel. I didn't eat in the restaurant. The people here are nice. The hotel, well, it's waaay... over priced for how close it is to the bed in a converted trailer I once stayed in in a remote part of Canada once. It was cleanand it kept the bears away. I was really tired once I got there, but had I not been, I would have left. The building has somepotential. The people are nice and the restaurant below seems popular with locals. Maybe it will be okay someday, but now itisn't. Read more
Lots of personality at this place and I was impressed by the draft selection. They let you have a sample of the beer before... committing to a pint, which is nice. The munchies are generous in portions and delicious. Read more
Aside from it taking an hour and a half to get our food, everyone was disappointed with their meal. The server barely made an... attempt to express concern on such a long ticket time. No management came to apologize or tell us our food would be out shortly.When our food did arrive the food runners got short with one of us when they asked for mustard for their burger. Two of usordered sandwiches that were extremely dry and the other two entrees were $20+ each had undercooked pasta. Would not recommendthis restaurant. There are better options for food and service. First time experience left a big impression to not waste ourtime again. Would?ve been faster to go to the grocery store and cook 5 different meals at home. Read more
If you like a clean restaurant with vintage design, good food and service this is the place for you. Went with a group of ten... people today. Everyone of us was treated special by our Waitress. Food was very delicious and the prices were just right. Read more
This was exactly what we were looking for on our trip back to Maryland from Vermont. It was a great little fine. The food was... great and they had a good selection of beers on tap. The room was less then 100 buck and included everything we needed for aquick overnight stay. Read more
How to turn a huge disappointment into a great WIN! We left the house expecting to dine at a different restaurant. When we... arrived we found the place locked up tight with no indication as to why. What to do? We saw folks walking into The Erie anddecided to give it a try. What a great surprise! Our waitress Amanda was just about the best, sweetest and cheeriest. The foodwas amazing. The included salad was perfect with great Blue Cheese dressing, the bread was scrumptious and the two entrees weretasty and plentiful. Read more
Food was very good. Restaurant was nice. Hotel was nice too but a little cold. The whole thing was very reasonably priced. Under... $100/night. Dinner was about $30 or so for just me; appetizer, main course, dessert. Read more