Reviews for Margarita's Cafe Smithtown in Port Washington, NY

Hands-down the best Mexican restaurant in town. Their entrees are very good, and the guacamole is top-notch. Sometimes if you... go, they'll have a mariachi band playing. Their outside seating is pretty nice too, as long as it's not too cold or raining. Thedrinks are great too -- the margarita's definitely live up to the name! I highly recommend! Read more

We’ve been going to Margarita’s for the last year and a half and this place does not disappoint ~ Friendly and... accommodating staff~ There’s a mariachi band that adds to the atmosphere ~ The food is consistent and portions are generous~ The staff will happily work around any dietary needs; which is appreciated ~ The restaurant is tucked into a great spot withsome nice parks across the street that you can walk to after dinner and enjoy. If you’re in the area , check outMargarita’s Cafe’. Read more

Loved the food, friendly and courteous staff in a lively atmosphere.

Their pitchers of margs are nothing to mess with! The food is delicious and filling Mexican food. The restaurant itself is... beautifully decorated! Read more

I have absolutely nothing negative to write about this fabulous restaurant. I don't often write reviews unless I am totally... impressed with the restaurant—their food, menu, ambiance, cleanliness, and service/servers. I was visiting my sister andbro-in-law in PW for the weekend. And, my sister suggested going out to dinner at a Mexican restaurant named Margarita's. Iwas okay with the idea but a bit skeptical since I live on the UES of Manhattan with five wonderful Mexican restaurants within a5 block distance from my apartment. Anyway, Margarita's Café was fantastic!!! The food was delicious and the servers wereamazingly attentive and super nice. The live music made for a fun Saturday night atmosphere. This restaurant did notdisappoint at all and I can't wait to visit my Sis again soon and go back to Margarita's. Read more

The food was delicious, truly authentic, and the atmosphere and ambiance was great. However, there were many small flies flying... around our table and the surrounding one's as well. They either looked like fruit flies, or tiny black flies, and I understandit's no one's fault, and it may be from some unforeseen circumstances. My sister literally killed like eight of them in a twominutes period, but otherwise it was a special night. Read more

Amazing lunch here. Steak fajitas and combo fajitas with chicken, steak and shrimp. Very good and very friendly service!

Delicious food and drinks. The atmosphere is nice and chill.