Reviews for Pizza Thief in Portland, OR
I feel like this place is too expensive @ $5 for a pepperoni slice. $28 for a cheese pie is absolutely wild.... and $2 for a... single dipping sauce...are you high??? I'm knocking off a star due to price. That being said, my slice was super thin and verycrispy, and clearly boasted high quality ingredients. Flavorful sauce and cheese, but the amount of both is lacking, in myopinion. Also, the pizza is maybe slightly too well done. The cheese has zero "pull" to it. Some of the best pepperonis thatI've had in a long time, though. Read more
Second stop on our Pizza Week pizza tour and it did not disappoint! The sauce was unlike anything I?d ever had. Really unique ... mix of ingredients. Knocked off a star because it didn?t taste very fresh and was just slightly warm. If it had been a fresh,hot slice it would?ve been a lot more enjoyable. Read more
Favorite pizza spot in Northwest Portland! I?ve been here a few times and the staff and quality of food is always consistent and... amazing! Definitely coming back! The connected bar next door is also great with a good cocktail menu. There is also a niceoutdoor seating option for nice days, and rainy cool days with a cover and heaters. This place is our favorite neighborhood spotfor sure! Read more
Some great pizza by the slices can be found here. We were in the area and grab a few slices to try out. The Hot Tony, sausage &... onion, and Wildwood Mushroom were the three that we tried. The Hot Tony was the most flavorful one and just had this addictingtaste that makes you want to keep on eating it. The other two were also pretty flavorful. They also have a bar next door thatyou can grab a drink and enjoy. Read more
This is my favorite place to get pizza in town! I usually come here a few times a week for an after work slice and I never get... sick of it because all of the slice options feel like their own individual meal. I mostly love the seasonal slice and how theytry to source as many ingredients as they can from the local farmers markets. The chocolate chip hazelnut cookie with sea saltis also something I can go there without getting, for sure a hidden bakery gem in the pizza shop! Nice patio for outdoor eatingand I also occasionally love the hibiscus/mezcal cocktail from their neighbor bandit bar. Read more
Really good pizza! Slices definitely could have been hotter, they only warmed them for a couple of minutes. I prefer my crust a... bit thicker and crispier. It was quite chewy. But all the toppings, the cheese, the sauce were excellent. Great service andowners!!! Read more
Pizza by the slice that is pretty dam good. As a native New Yorker for over 20 years I am still shocked when I find good pizza... in PDX? especially when you can get it by the slice. Pizza thief has it going on! This pizza passes the fold test (see my pic).Sauce and cheese are spot on. Their pepperoni is a list. The interior and exterior dining are great to either chill with abeverage or grab a slice and go. My kind of pizza joint !! My slices has been a little extra baked then I?d normally prefer butis not a deal breaker. I think this is one of the harder things to get right when you offer by the slice options. Go here totaste some great pizza and sip some beers or wine. Their beverage fridge is excellent. The staff is super friendly. Positivevibes all around ! Read more
Seasonal Artichoke pie was incredible. Standard cheese and mushroom was perfection. The crust is chewy and crunchy in all the... best ways. Don't sleep on the cheese bread! Read more