Reviews for Mama Lucia in Potsdam, NY
Absolutely delicious food, with a great atmosphere and excellent service from Nate. This is awesome and authentic Italian food!... Be prepared though, this is fine dining and portions are definitely small. Prices reflect the excellent quality of the food. Wasit pricey? I think it was worth every delicious penny. Read more
It was ok. I had high expectations based on a previous review. Appetizers and salad were tasty but entrees were bland. ... Servers were pleasant enough. Read more
The first time my boyfriend has never finished his plate. Mozzarella bread appetizer way over cooked. Medium steak over cooked... and over seasoned. My lemon pesto chicken was only lemon with watery sauce. Frozen broccoli, with a 30 dollar meal and 14 dollardrinks. Waiter was friendly though! Never again. Read more
Our server, L.J. was phenomenal! Our family enjoyed a wonderful meal from start to finish. The food was well prepared,... presented, and delicious! The atmosphere of this establishment is outstanding. It is family friendly, and we felt very welcomed.The restaurant was recommended to us from our server, Lexie (from Maxfields). Read more
I reviewed the menu on-line, where it stated that the large Roma pizza was $18.99; with tax, I was expecting to pay a little... over $20.00. When I arrived to pick up my pizza, I was charged $25.90. I was told that the menu prices had just changed; a$3.00 increase, along with a $2.00 to go fee. I responded that these charges were not noted on the web-site. No one seemed tocare, so I regretfully paid it. To make matters worse, when I finally saw my pizza, half of it was burnt and inedible. Itypically love this restaurant. Super disappointed... Read more
As others have said, the wait is long, Caesar salad inedible, stuffed shells served burnt and dry (after waiting over an... hour)and chicken park comes with no pasta ?because the chef is funny about it..? Family size stuffed shells that are touted asserving 3-4 in fact serve no more than 2 and is a whopping $27. For something with no meat or salad. Meatballs tasted like 50%oregano and no garlic. Member of our party complained to the owner who comped the bill but told him ?never come back.? (!!) Ifyou?re shortstaffed, close for the day like other places. But don?t make the customer suffer. An hour and a half I sat therehungry only to be served some nasty shells. It?s too bad because between the excellent atmosphere, awesome bread and the goodsauce base you could really do much better. Bathroom reeked of sewer. I don?t know how the tables next to the bathroom doorcould stand it. Read more
We love this place for quality Italian dishes in a casual atmosphere. Service is always friendly and willing to make adjustments... for our toddler. The wood fired oven pizza is an absolute must! Read more
The waiters were very nice and attentive but that?s the only good thing I can say. Food was mediocre at best. Alfredo is... supposed to be creamy, not taste like dishwater. 9 people and we got our meals 2 at a time. One person didn?t even get theirsuntil everyone else was almost done. Another group arrived 30 minutes after us and got their food way before we did. They saidthey would discount the bill but when it showed up there was nothing discounted or removed. Would definitely not recommend. Read more