Reviews for Potsdam Little Italy in Potsdam, NY
Minimal toppings on pizzas, they like to skimp all the way around. Dressings/drinks have been forgotten on orders the past few... times I've ordered delivery. It's not worth the prices they charge. Sergis Pizza > Little Italy, 100%. Read more
It was the gals first day working at the pizzeria and she /they messed up our order and we had to wait another 25min to have it... replaced. They did give us the pizza they made wrong which was cool but I think since we had to wait so long they didn't let thepizza cook long enough so it wasn't at its peak of pizza perfection. We put it in the oven the next day to reheat it and it wasmuch better. Read more
Walked into a restaurant full of pizza oven smoke. Wasn?t going to stay but was from out of town ? The service was ok. The... food was not that good. Bruschetta was awful . Pasta was swimming in sauce and it was not hot. ???? This place caters to takeout pizza orders for college students. Constant traffic right past out table for take outs . It?s unfortunate . Read more
Second time here and the service is superb! We are Asians and were treated with respect and hospitality by the staff unlike... other bad experiences we had at other restaurants. Food is decent and affordable, we really like the buffalo wings! Willdefinitely be back again to try other items on the menu :) Read more
Get a slice or two to dine-in or to go and enjoy it in the park that's a quick walk away. Pizza is very good, cobb salad is... good, but everything else leaves a little to be desired. We ordered a side of meatballs and they came sauceless (lol). Deliveryusing the app is confusing, they estimate 60-90 minutes but it came in 30 which was great, but still confusing. Read more
I haven't ordered pizza here for a couple of years soni thought I'd give it a try. We ordered an extra large pizza with half... meatball and half fresh garlic, mushrooms onions and peppers. We also ordered a dozen garlic knots and an antipasto salad. Thesalad was ok. It was what you might expect from a local pizza place. The garlic knots were also ok. One box was pretty goodand the other six were clearly old and had been sitting around for hours. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. I love pizzaand can forgive a lot of things, but this was raw in the middle. Clearly whoever is in the kitchen has no idea what they aredoing. The meatball half was swimming in grease. It was pooled in the middle. The veggie half was soaking wet and clearly hadnot been cooked enough. I would have taken it back except my whole family was starving and so we choked down a couple piecesand threw out the rest see pictures below if you want to see what Little Italy in Potsdam is selling customers. Read more
Very little cheese or toppings, mostly just crust and sauce. Literally a solid 3 inches of crust before you reach the cheese... zone in many spots, which itself has huge crust bubbles that again have no cheese on them (see the picture). Unimpressive andunsatisfying, to be honest. Frozen is better if you're on the fence. Read more
I ordered online at 8:30 and it said it would be delivered at 10. I never even got my order!! I tried to call but the voicemail... just kept saying they were closed. DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I paid $28 and got no food :(. Hoping they will fix this tomorrowbecause I am now going to bed hungry -edited to say they had great customer service and helped me out the next day. I never gotany phone calls and I put in the right phone number so I have no clue what happened. I would still recommend not ordering onlineit seems like their system needs work but other than that really good people and I appreciate their swift response ! Read more