Reviews for Goodfellas Pizzeria & Restaurant in Poughkeepsie, NY

Amazing pizza! Great service

Pizza is always great and never flops over. Very crunchy crust. Excellent!!!!

We had a good pizza here. Would have been better with fresh mushrooms.

No air conditioning. Calzone i ordered was awful. Could not chew !

Come here for lunch often. I get the Buffalo chicken pizza and my fiance gets chicken marsala pizza, both are amazing! They even... let us, at North East Ford, put up our display featuring our $2 inspection stickers! Thank you! Read more

So let?s talk about Goodfellas?..this place has become a staple in my family for the last 8 years. I have been bringing my kids... here since before they could walk, and now they are like family. But let?s put the great experiences and friendly atmosphereaside?.the food is great. I have never had a bad pie or a meal that was anything less than delicious. This place is great andthat is why they have been in business for so long. You will not be disappointed, go here and get a great meal. Read more

Moved to the area 2 years ago. Bounced around pizzerias trying to see what's what... Found myself going back to Goodfellas time... again. They have a wide menu for a pizzeria restaurant, pizza quality/size is great, diner dishes are splendid. If you haveallergies, you just need to clearly communicate and they will help as much as possible. Dinning in is separate/offset from thepizza counter which is nice. They do charge $1 or so for card charge which is expected. Long story short - best pizzeria in thespackenkill area by lengths. Read more

I've ordered 2 times. Grilled chicken Caesar salad. By far the best I have ever had! The grilled chicken is delicious and all... cut up. Just excellent! Read more