Reviews for Mel's Pizza Pasta & More in Poughkeepsie, NY

I can't believe I haven't reviewed one of my most visited places to eat. I have been eating at Mel's before ownership changed... and they still maintain great, high, fresh food standards. Their pizza is some of the best around and their specialty pies arealways delicious. They pop out a little before lunch and definitely sell out! Their soups are delicious, their subs and wrapsare a lunch favorite. Their garlic knots are award worthy, they are perfectly toasted and come with so much garlic on top. Iwill try to remember to post more pictures of their food, but most of the time we dive right in! Read more

Fantastic pizza! The buffalo chicken is our favorite. Edit: I was initially hooked on this place because it was the only one... around with a more traditional/thicker pizza crust. My last few pizzas here have been super thin, which is disappointing for me.However, I won't lower my rating since that is just my preference. Edit 2: I will try asking for thicker crust on my nextorder! ???? Read more

Even after a year and with a new owner this pizzeria has been doing amazing, the food the service, everything! It’s... impeccable. I’ll be looking forward to coming here more often. Read more

Mel can cook! Great quality of food, you can tell the difference between boring pizza joints. They make a ton of recipes from... scratch, sauces etc… Also, the Wings and Gyros are on another level. 5/5 Yes I said Gyros made fresh in house! Read more

This is hands down the best pizza place in the area it’s definitely our number one go to. Everything is delicious - from their... pizza to their sandwiches to their salads. Try their salad pizza - you won’t regret it! Read more

Finally! Found good pizza in the area! Moved from Orange County and could not believe how different and bad the pizza was. This... pizza is amazing and the dough is the way it should be, soft chewy and bubbly, unlike all the other places that have thisstrange flat bland dough. And the sauce is delicious! Can’t wait to try more from here :) Read more

Literally EVERYTHING we get from Sinapi's is 10 out of 10! Pizza, hero's, wraps, pasta and fries... everything is so good!!!... It's hard to find a place that is constantly on point! Unfortunately we are moving down south in a few days. We are going toDEEPLY miss this place! We have ordered every dinner here for the past week because we are packing and I'm not getting bored!!!When we come back to NY to visit, Sinapi's is going to be the first thing I'm ordering!! Complements to the chef ???????????? Read more

I asked for Recommendations on Fish and chips and tried Peter Sinapi’s on 376 that got 3 recommendations. The Fish was very... fresh Cod, the Guinness batter lite and very tasty. Also had the Minestrone soup and the clams all very tasty. Like thefriendly family atmosphere. Read more