Reviews for Milk & Cookies in Princeton, NJ
I stopped in recently heading back to the Jersey Shore after a night in Princeton and so glad I did! I couldn't decide on one... brownie, so I ordered a bunch -- the "monster' was by far our favorite! It has toffee, chocolate and not sure what else but itwas sooo good. I also grabbed a bag of granola which is some of the best granola I've ever had! Coffee was hot and strong andservice was great. I'll definitely be back! Read more
My girlfriend and I actually stumbled upon this little cookie bakery by accident, not knowing if it was actually open or not.... The interior smells of baked goods such as cookies and brownies. We got a sugar cookie with a chocolate chunk cookie, and asmall iced mocha drink. The workers were very kind and the cookies and drink were very sweet and tasty! We?ll be sure to stop byagain on our next walk Read more
UPDATE: this place is, indeed, just as nice in the summer ?? as the winter ?, even with the fascinating little situation of... multiple students from Rider working directly across from the campus of Princeton, or the fact that I felt sort of guilty aboutordering one brownie, one ???? shake, and multiple cups ???? of lemonade ???? (it should honestly be considered *illegal*, atleast within the deepest reaches of *my own mind*, for the same little place to make so many incredibly delicious things ????????), all within the same afternoon/evening (sorry about that, girls; I know you claimed not to be bothered by that, but,surely, you must prefer seeing different people on each of your shifts...); I even got into this interesting little chat aboutthe downtown area in Princeton with one of them that evening, along with others similar to it here in Jersey (Hoboken;Montclair; Morristown; Ridgewood, etc., and to, maybe, a slightly lesser extent, Asbury Park/Long Branch/New Brunswick/etc.),*so discussing something other than the actual menu*, for once, seemingly, was obviously even better still than simplydiscussing the menu once again - I'll definitely make sure to stop by at least once more the remainder of this summer ???????? Finally got around to trying this place after various instances of attending events on the Princeton campus within thesepast few years (especially hockey) - this place is very "cozy"; the employees are very kind, as well (and certainly particularlyseem to love hearing from first time visitors like myself, and this group of friends that was here during my little visit, atleast from what I noticed then), and, obviously, considering the menu here, it definitely seems likely to satisfy pretty muchevery type of "sweet tooth", like my lifelong one of those, and, obviously, after that experience, I'll definitely returnsometime soon, most likely during the summer, to be able to visit this collegiate downtown area more generally on a differenttyp Read more
What a sweet delight as I walked by and saw the words that make my heart beat faster: Cookies!! Upon entering, you get hit with... all your senses. Your nose smells all those freshly baked goods. Your eyes dance with delight as you see brownies, cookies, anddrinks (psst, they serve more than just milk). Ohhhh the smells of all that wonderful goodness! You can hear the patron's joy asthey bite into their edibles. Finally, the taste as you bite into your cookie or brownie. After our senses finally calmed down,Hubby and I got down to business. After purchasing and sharing several cookies and brownies between us, we both favored theiroriginal brownies the most. It was not overly sweet and tasted like Devil?s Food cake but in a brownie, instead.Delectable! Each cookie is $2.75 but if you purchase 12 cookies, you save $3 and pay $30. The Big Brownie is $4.50 and worthevery penny! The shop is cozy and takes you back in a time to be in one of those wonderful sitcom kitchens where you expect amom to come out and just treat you with warm baked cookies after a hard day. No need to have a hard day to get these yummies. Itis on the main strip on Nassau Street. They have bistro tables for you to stay and enjoy or you can take them to go. Read more
Nice selection of baked goods including brownies and rice krispies, besides their wide selection of cookies. The cookies were... not very fresh and were quite sweet, but the texture was nice. Overall, if you're passing by, I wouldn't vote against goingthere, but I think that there are better dessert spots nearby in Princeton. Read more
Chocolate cookies are excellent, what else? A small shop on Nassau but a large choice of fresh, colored and tasty products. Kind... staff. Give it a try! Read more
A hidden gem in Princeton! Milk and Cookies is a small bakery on Chambers Street that serves amazing cookies, milkshakes, and... ice cream sandwiches. They offer gluten-free, vegan, or both! Their prices are very cheap considering on how good their dessertsare. They also offer online delivery for their cookies, which me and my friends often use. Their assortment of desserts anddrinks is just astounding, and I'm very surprised that not a lot of people actually go there (from my experience). The staffthere are very kind, and take time to get your order right, and please you. Thanks Milk and Cookies! Read more
Nice treat. Great options. Fresh grab and go.