Reviews for New London Pizza - Since 1974 in Prospect Park, PA

Everything I have tried is delicious and they are fast! Good people.

My family has been going here since the 1970s. Delicious pizza all around, tasty hamburgers, mozzarella sticks, chicken, etc.... Mike is an amazing guy and super dedicated to the shop. Read more

In town visiting family and found New London Pizza when looking for lunch options today. Everything about my experience was... exceptional. Online ordering was intuitive and very user friendly. The quoted time for pickup was spot on. Customer serviceupon walking in was straight to the point with no wait. I ordered a small white pizza with tomato and ricotta cooked extra welllight. It was as ordered and delicious. My wife ordered the Italian grinder and raved about it. Naturally, I had to taste it. Ican see why she raved about it. It was very tasty. Our granddaughter ordered chicken nuggets. Like most children her age, she'sa chicken nugget connoisseur. ???? She said they were the best! As a business owner myself, i know many small business -especially restaurants - have a high failure rate. It's easy to see how New London Pizza has not just survived, but thrivedwith loyal customers for almost 50 years. Overall, we truly enjoyed our experience and will order again when we come back tovisit. Read more

It?s been years since I?ve had New London. After moving back to Prospect Park is was my first order. As always, the pizza was... delicious. I personally got Feta and Chicken. One of my favorite combinations. On the New London style of pizza, it wasdelicious! Was very happy to enjoy it again. Read more

It's Pizza what can you say about pizza everyone loves pizza picked up some pies for the fam. Order the heads it was ready when... we got there nice and hot when we got home would recommend stopping in and having a bite Read more

Use to be my goto pizza in this area but something has changed don't know if it is the cheese the sauce or the people. Still... good just not as good. I will keep trying but no longer my goto place. I hope they get back whatever is missing really enjoyedthis place and it might just be a slump all places have one. Wishing them the best. Read more

I am originally from Prospect Park and though I have traveled far and wide on this planet, I return to New London pizza as often... as I can knowing I am in for a treat. This unique, crispy, cheesy and satisfying pan pizza always makes my day. The staff isfriendly, efficient and well trained when it comes to having my order ready on time. As a Chef and restaurateur I highlyrecommend giving this little space with the big taste a try. Read more

Unfortunately for this $10.25 Steak Royal the day before I had a very very good Steak Royal for $8. What I love about this... Steak Royal and I hope I see on all future Steak Royals is sliced cheese melted to the roll. I think this really helps holdjuices in and stops roll failure. The people were very nice but other than that I really did not care for this cheesesteak. Itwas good but could have been a lot better. Good Cheesesteak experience. Read more