Reviews for The New Anchor Inn in Punxsutawney, PA
We were there for a funeral dinner. Service was excellent. Food was very good. I will return.
Pizza was burnt around edges and crust was very hard..if I would have opened box before I got home I would have refused it.
The food here is nothing short of amazing! Truly, it was some of the best lasagna, and mac n cheese we've ever had! The... wonderful waitress took great care of us despite the fact that we accidentally came in near closing. The web site said 9, butthey were closed earlier. They still seated us and took good care of us. It's such an impeccably clean establishment. Theatmosphere is a warm and inviting one. I highly reccomend this is you like Italian, and home made food. They make their foodfresh in house. There plenty of room to accommodate parties of any size. Definitely worth a drive. I HIGHLY reccomend thisplace. We called around other places and the people were rude, this place took us in and fed us. Please stop in! Read more
Great food, enjoyed the Italian sampler. The steak sub was good too, the roll was a little thick. We ordered take out and dine... in too. Read more
What can I say. Been coming here since I was sitting in a high chair. Flew home last weekend from Colorado. Just to get a... pizza. ( and a second one to bring back on the plane) A Punxsy staple. Please support this business so it can continue toserve that magic people to the Punxsy area ( and me next time I fly home). I have already made plans to have 4 or 5 of thembought and shipped out here from local friends Read more
After working a wine festival all day this was the only place we saw that was open still after 8pm. We walked in as they were... getting ready to close due to being slow... they had everything cleaned and put away... they didn't even blink an eye when weasked if we could still get food. The owner came out and asked how we were and offered us suggestions on food. The pizza,spaghetti, manicotti, lasagna and meatballs were amazing! And the sauce was AWESOME!!!! We will definitely be back andappreciate the owner and his staff for remaining open!!! Read more
I did not have a good experience with this place. Service was good, and they did take the food we didn't eat off the bill it is... a nice place. The chicken parmesan was bad, the spaghetti was really dry. Some of the bacon in my loaded mashed potatoes had amaple syrup taste to it almost like the bacon was leftovers from the morning. The shrimp dinner was ok. The mild chicken wingshad no flavor. The bread was good. Read more
Looking at google reviews, this place should have been amazing. It was anything but. The food was bland and microwaved, at... best. Got a glass of wine and it had soured. I ordered shrimp scampi and I'm pretty certain it was microwaved. It was blandand rubbery. My eldest ordered manicotti. She said that it was alright. Youngest ordered a sirloin, the menu said that it wassirloin, but it turned out to be fillet. That was the only decent part of any of our meals. Her mashed potatoes were instantand the gravy was obviously canned. My wife ordered a t-bone. The meat was then and not cooked as she requested(rare). Thewaitress was good and attentive, but busy. Since she was under 16, she couldn't be the person to bring us our alcoholicbeverages; this was interesting. Ultimately, this is a one star establishment. The only saving grace was the waitress beingattentive and working hard. Read more