Reviews for Frostys Bar & Family Pizza Big Man's Burrito Stand in Put-In-Bay, OH

We have been going here for pizza for years and absolutely love it. On our last trip to the Bay we went for breakfast, our... waiter was awful, clearly did not want to be there and served our breakfast that we waited a long time for cold. I get it theywere busy, we were fine with waiting but that bartender server really ruined the start of our day. Read more

The pizza was hot and loaded with cheese and pepperoni. We ordered traditional and Buffalo chicken. It did not disappoint. Cold... pitchers of beer too. They offered a good variety of novelty clothing and many of us purchased some cute T shirts while we werewaiting for our food to arrive. we would definitely return. Read more

Stopped in for a drink Saturday night came back for breakfast Sunday morning. The back patio is really nice. The Meager Kings... were playing. They were a great band!! They had one of the best sets. They were very talented and entertaining!! They kept usthere for way more than the one drink we had planned on. Had the Mexican sunrise for breakfast and it was really good. Read more

Frostys and one other location came up as the two best Pizza places to eat while at The Bay, I thought Frostys appeared more... appealing with the frosted mugs. We were drawn in by the lure of frosted beer mugs and live music, with an overwhelming smellof Pizza. Honestly, who could resist? Once inside there are two separate sides, connected by open spaces, yet designed in a waywhich divides them very clearly for dining and drinking. This made easy to go to the side in which catered to your currentneeds, and for fast service regarding both. We had an incredible amount of drinks, and ordered two pizzas. The drinks werestrong, and priced reasonably. The Pizza's, were incredible. Extremely fresh, and hot. Frankly, most of the week, food was abig disappointment - but Frostys delivered on the best Pizza, and my best meal, entirely for our trip. Staff was very friendlyand pleasant, efficient, and fun. Definitely stop here, especially at dinner time... Read more

Breakfast was very good, fast service and great unlimited coffee. Eggs Benedict was the best I've ever had! Stopped another day... for dinner. Ordered the Italian sandwich - I would not recommend it, there is very little meat on it. Also - the loaded totstasted like they were microwaved. Read more

I really love the atmosphere here and the music, I haven't eat here but the drinks are pretty good. Great time with family and... friends ?? love Put n Bay!! Read more

Breakfast was super expensive and not good. Eggs overcooked and tasted nasty. Bacon tasted like the detergent they use to clean... the oven trays (I used to wash dishes, it's a very distinct smell). Absolutely sub-par, would not recommend Read more

Very crowded on the day we went. Pizzas were fine, but rest of the items are average. Service was faster and attentive. But the... food tastes very average. Food was expensive but that?s through out Put In Bay. Over all passable experience. Read more