Reviews for Goat Soup & Whiskey in Put-In-Bay, OH
Probably the best meal I have had in a very long time. Everything was just perfect. Had the beet salad, fish taco and my... husband had the half salad with choice of two soups. A great lunch and great atmosphere. Read more
Restaurant was amazing. It should have been for the price. It is a classy place with melt in your mouth filet mignon, exquisite... taste al dente vegetables and baked potato. Unbelievable bread and great service. If you want excellence, stop in, but have alarge wallet. Attached are two stores on the lower level worth seeing. Chocolate and German tastes. Read more
Visited this place for the first time on island. Lamb chops were medium done, so dint really enjoy them, fries and tater tots... were all salty. Shrimp poboyes were good, perogie stuffed with pasta were mediocre, thai crunch salad was yum. Drinks were niceand outdoor seating could not acvonodate large groups but can be seated there to enjoy outdoor. Read more
Great place for dinner, both entrees and appetizer were good. Had a marvelous Key Lime Martini! The service was excellent. If... you are wanting to dine here definitely make reservations, it's worth it. Read more
The best food on Put-in-Bay, hands down. And the best espresso martini I've ever had in my entire life. The clam chowder was the... best I've ever had as well. Large variety of options on the menu. Lovely patio area for outdoor dining. I make it a point toalways visit here when I'm on the island. Can't wait to go back! Read more
YUMMMMM! I fell in love with the landscape of this beautiful eatery and was so pleasantly surprised to know that they had... equally delightful food! Loved that the menu wasn't super large...indicates that they focus on quality, not quantity! Our fungroup enjoyed the outdoor patio sipping on refreshing cocktails...the blueberry, mint mojito was by far the best cocktailordered! I loved that it wasn't too sweet. We all ordered different items, but the consensus was that the perch tacos were thefavorite. Not much for vegan/vegetarian options, so I went with a reuben minus the corned beef served with beer battered fries.Yummy!!! It was a weird order, but the server didn't miss a beat with my special request. And I must mention that our serverwas absolutely delightful...attentive, funny, and reminded me of Amy Schumer...adorable!! I would highly recommend Goat!!! Read more
Fantastic food tonight. Enjoyed the escargot and got my party to try them after some explaining and they were delicious. Also... had the chicken marsala and Walleye Oscar. Very happy with the food and service will be happy to come back again. Read more
This place accommodated our whole bachelorette party and we had exceptional service and fantastic food! The tortilla soup was... outstanding and my fish tacos were also really good. We ordered tons of their appetizers to split between the table and everyonecommented on how amazing their food was. We had about 20 people and everyone walked away Impressed. The staff is extremelyfriendly and accommodating for our large group as well. Please be mindful at this place. Only takes reservations now. Read more