Reviews for The Keys in Put-In-Bay, OH
Amazing food. I ventured out of my comfort zone for arguably the best sandwich I?ve had at Put-in-Bay. The blackened grilled... cheese on Texas toast. So good! Add in amazing service and atmosphere and you can?t go wrong at The Keys! Read more
We ordered fish finger?s appetizer, the breading was too hard and it was mostly just breading, almost no fish. It?s was $16,... it?s a joke! Kids meal ($12) fish sticks, same story. Kids meal ($12) Mac and cheese - I am 99% sure is from the Kraft box. Notworth it at all :(. Read more
Stopped here on a Tuesday in the summer at 2 PM and was seated right away. Nice view of the bay. Had the Blackened Mahi Mahi... sandwich with sweet potato fries and my husband had the Cuban. He said it was one of the best Cubans he?s ever had. The sweetpotato fries were worth the extra up charge as the side to my sandwich. The service was fast and friendly! Read more
Super menu. Food is delicious. For vegetarian, black bean burger with a side of rice and beans, sweet potato fries is great.... Their chicken soup is good too. Great service. Outdoor seating is pleasant except for the fact that could see few water snakes.Nice ambience. Neat restrooms. Read more
Great food, service was very good. Our family of five was not disappointed with the burgers, chicken fingers and fries that was... ordered. One of the specials was fries with pulled pork, melted cheddar and jalapenos, I left the jalapenos off, it wasdelicious. Will definitely go back! Read more
Cute decor. I ordered the Buffalo chicken Flatbread and my bestie had the Island Tacos. Unfortunately the service was extremely... slow and the waitress totally forgot things we asked for. Not to mention my friend's dish had literally no mango in a dish thatboasted of mangos. Also the entire Island Taco dish was bland. Pretty sure we will come back to PIB, just not at this place. Read more
The food and atmosphere are amazing! We got a table right on the water and got a great view of Perry?s monument, geese and even... some water snakes! Beside the view the food was all amazing, we tried the Hemingway burger and it was delicious along with theseasoned fries! Read more
DON'T GO HERE. Hostess Karen rudely told us Dining only at tables, must sit at bar. We had 6 people. Bar area empty. Tables at... bar empty inside. Outside dining maybe 4 to 6 people. Stools outside, with a little ledge, no one would have room to eat there.We were going to sit at those bar stools on the right outside there for drinks. Hostess Karen came in & rudely yelled at usagain. Tables are only for people dining. Really no one there & You close at 7pm. Use some common sense, you make money onalcohol. You cut off your nose to spite your face! 6 people who would have got 2 drinks & tips left & went to anotherestablishment. Read more