Reviews for GoodFellas pizzeria of SunnySide in Queens, NY
10/10 good cheap pizza. Friendly service $22 for 4 slices of pizza, cheese garlic knots, and 3 drinks
Best pizza I?ve had in NY yet! Will definitely order again next time I?m in town! Thanks for the wonderful pie!
The best in the neighborhood, what else you ask for when you can get a slice of hot spicy and crunchy pie at 8pm!
Best deal for any student I SWEAR, also considering everything else the pizza was like a 20 out of 10.
The place is new and very clean, everyone was nice and friendly and the garlic knots are decent but the pizza was not good at... all. The sauce tasted like it came out of a cheap can, the New York style slice was drenched in oil to the point where it wassoggy and falling apart but the crust was okay, the sicilian slice was better but the crust was burned to a crisp and it tastedburned. Not only is the pizza not well made, it is very over priced. I paid $11 for two slices and garlic knots. Also I have noidea how they got so many reviews when they just opened, regardless if the pizza is improved and the prices are lowered it willbe a great pizzeria. Read more
First let me get this out of the way. I was given the opportunity to have two slices for free here via Yelp Elite. I did however... also buy 4 other slices that were not complementary. I went in with high hopes of this being a great spot for a slice, andespecially since this is my first time having a Yelp funded experience. The 3 stars is solely for the food. It would be 3.5 butyou can\'t do half a star. The half would be for the friendly staff & clean place.\n\nThe atmosphere is nice. It\'s a small spotwith some decent decor. Nothing screamed \"GoodFellas / Mafia\" from the name. Two large tv screens with the menu & a third withtheir business name.\n\nFood: Regular slice is ok. Nothing that would make me come back, or sadly tell anyone about. Thespecialty slice I had, chicken & ranch, was good. It tasted fresh & the crust was nice. It was lacking in flavor a bit. Iordered the Sicilian / Grandma slice. It wasn\'t that good. It has a weird after taste to it. The Buffalo chicken was meh. Thechicken on top was kinda mushy in texture.\nNow the star was the vegetable slice. That was yummy. It was fresh & tasted good.Sadly not enough to warrant the drive here.\n\nOverall not a bad spot to hit if you\'re nearby, but not worth a drive. Parkingis hard around here.\n\n**My Yelp review I stated I didn?t get my drinks. I know the sign says ?cheese? however the guy servingme said he?d give it to me. Didn?t say you we?re being petty? @Andres/Owner ?- you say you want criticism but your attitude &response says otherwise. Read more
The decor of Goodfellas Pizza is humble as typical pizza spots in the neighborhood but also clean & bright. The owner was super... friendly, welcoming and introduced everything in details.\n\nThere is a good variety of flavors and we had 2 slices of originalcheese & tomato pizza, 1 slice of meat lover deep dish and 1 slice of chicken ranch pizza with 2 Diet Cokes to share for dinner.The pizza was overall decent with a great amount of ingredients. Read more
The sauce was filled with herbs and spices that tasted fresh. Cheese wasn\'t overloaded and greasy, just the right amount AND... NOT OILY.\n\nWill definitely return if I\'m in Sunnyside, definitely a must try if you\'re in the area! Read more