Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in Mt Pleasant, WI

A little funky on service but almost got it right. The inside is unruly and slightly unclean. Did stay and eat. Sub was good and... filling. Read more

They make everything fresh after you order. Everybody there is friendly and efficient. And the food is really good.

Slow service, chaotic. Got my order wrong. Asked for no mayo, was smothered in n mayo. Also left bacon off club sandwich as a... salad. One out of three orders was right. The Manager was running around like a chicken with his head cut off. Was obviouslyfrazzled due to busy time and lack of good help. One employee was walking around and doing a whole lot of nothing. When Iarrived was not greeted until about 5 min by the frazzled manager, who was less than friendly. My order had been ready the wholetime, saw it sitting there on the back counter. May want to have a separate stand for pre paid orders, non food deliveries orsomething. This bad experience really makes me want to never return. P S thanks for putting mayo on my sandwich, I've haddiarrhea 4 times . That is why I said no mayo Read more

This is my new favorite sub shop!! You're definitely not skimped on toppings or meat!! The meat is cut to order and cooked to... order!! Love, love, love it!!! Read more

After a frustrating morning at work, I walked in hungry with limited time, not knowing what to eat, after walking in seen the... place was alil busy , jeo was very helpful he suggested a few sandwiches and combos they had followed by him finishing up myorder in a very quick time. I really appreciate him and the whole team. Thanks i will mostlike be back at that location Read more

They keep forgetting items for my orders. When everything comes, it's a 30% chance something is wrong with at least one of the... items. It's great food if you get it and you win the dice roll of it being right.?????????????????? Read more

Every time I've gone here, the staff is so incredibly nice. They are pleasant and extremely accommodating, even when there's a... long line. I love going here just because of how great the service is. Now if they can just lower their prices by 2 or 3 dollarsfor a giant sub. Read more

Awesome experience at this location, excellent customer service and super helpful and tasty sandwiches! I love how they slice... the deli meat to order right in front of you! Super fresh ingredients and yummy fresh bread! We split the gigantic club and theywere so great about cutting it in half and putting our different toppings on it. We got it to go and when we got home theamazing employee wrote his and hers on the sandwiches. Such great service, it made me smile!!! Highly recommend this location!We will definitely be back! Read more