Reviews for Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room RSM in Rancho Santa Margarita, CA

Went in and there wasnt that many people in the restaurant. We were seated right away and no one ever came over to even get our... drink order. A couple that came in after us was waited on and that's when I decided to leave. This is the second time this hashappened to us at the rancho santa margarita location. Your food is great but you need to fix your service. Read more

Grabbed dinner before a movie. Service was friendly. Food arrived promptly and was adequate temperate. Recommend the... bruschetta Caesar salad. Boneless wings were good also. Good selection of beers on tap. Read more

Best pizza I?ve ever had. Hands down . That Chicago Pizza Pie was insane! Highly recommended to any pizza lovers

Fantastic selection of delicious pizzas, pastas, salads, sandwiches and wings! I?ve never been disappointed by the food or large... selection of rotating craft beers. It?s been a favorite spot of mine for years! Read more

Been coming to Selmas for a very long time now( i still miss the boneless wings from the mid 2000s) and this place never... disappoints! Best O Pesto pasta is so good and the Pedal to the Medal pizza is delicious! Read more

Order to go. Pizza was way over cooked. Rolls were soggy and doughy. Trashed them. Soup and salad were good or I would have... given one star. We ate one piece each only because we were super hungry. Like always, Service was slow and par. The onlything I like about this place is their beer. I give up on the food and service. Read more

Service was good however we sat and waited 45 mins when no one else was in the restaurant for our pizza, when it came out it was... obviously burnt and had barley melted cheese on it, it was obvious they had cooked the pizza too long , then scrapped off thecheese and tried to melt new cheese on it. It seemed like it would have been good if it was prepared the correct way. My sonwouldn?t eat it, it was literally black under the cheese, so we ordered chicken tenders to go. When we got home the chickentender was cut in half as if they were checking to see if it were cooked all the way. U don?t give a customer a chicken tenderthat was cut in half it looks nasty my son will not eat that either. I just don?t understand this kind of judgement from thekitchen staff. We paid and got boxes but most likely it will get thrown out. We didn?t realize how bad it was until we broughtit home. Also the amount of fries that came with the chicken tenders was an extremely small and now we are wondering if someoneate this!!! Really really horrible. Read more

Ordered takeout (small pedal to the metal Chicago pie, turkey sandwich, meatball sandwich, and party ship cookie) $60. After... reading the reviews we were excited for chicago pie. The crust was more of a deep dish bjs pizza (kinda soggy soft and geasy).The meatball was unfortunately bland. The beer battered fries with the sandwich were soggy and kind of a weird menu item. I'msure they would have been better dine in and not take out. The cookie was burnt and hard to bite through. Overall the only itemthat tasted as expected was the turkey sandwich. Read more