Reviews for Mr Crabby's Seafood House & Sports Bar (NJ) in Randolph, NJ

Had a perfect date night over the weekend. Nothing like starting with some Blue Moons. Didn't get a pic, but had a Shrimp... Cocktail and the Lobster & Crab Wontons. They were delicious! Our entrees, the Crabby Chefs Paella and the New England StyleLobster Rolls, were great servings, and very tasty. And our waitress was attentive and provided great service. Looking forwardto our next visit. Read more

I’ve been wanting to come to Mr. Cabby’s for a while now. Drove 40 minutes and we do not regret it at all! All the food was... great. We ordered the calamari (10/10) mahi tacos, the clam linguine and kids mozzarella sticks. The Long Mango Branch was soyummy and the perfect drink for a light weight like myself. Can’t wait to return with just my honey so we can hang out by thebar and enjoy one of the live bands. Our server Dave was very attentive and we look forward to having him serve us again. Read more

Best place for seafood ! I had the shrimp tacos and truffle fries. They were so good and fresh. Nico, Nicole, Amanda C, Amanda D... & Eddie served my party and they were so attentive and helpful. I highly recommend this place for drinks and a satisfying meal. Read more

Excellent!!! Great vibe, food was spectacular and great service. The new ownership definitely knows what they're doing!!! great... spot for seafood. We sat out the patio and it added so much atmosphere to our meal. There was a DJ and some sort of “guess thesong” bingo happening which was fun. They seem to have a lot of planned events coming up definitely worth checking out! Read more

Came for an early dinner. Beautiful day to sit outside. Great music. Great service. We started with steamers and raw clams. ... Then magi Maui tacos and a Tuscan Tuna salad. All very fresh, and tasty. We highly recommend. Read more

This place is great! We’ve been to this location numerous times over the past year. The food and service was ok but has since... improved significantly! The seafood is fresh and the portions are great. We’ve enjoyed everything that we’re orderedrecently. The drink buckets are also great! The servers are attentive and contribute to the great ambiance. It has great outdoorseating and is great for drinks after work or for a fun date night. I hope you all enjoy as much as we have! Read more

I have passed this restaurant so many times and finally I got a chance to try it. I called in my order of the shrimp tacos and... it came to a little under $15. When I arrived I parked in the private lot. I walked in and found the nice man that took myorder. He handed me my food, I paid and left. When I ate the tacos were good and so were the seasoned french fries. I enjoyedthe meal. Read more

Driven past it since it opened few years ago and never stop to try it - until I saw all the great reviews. So finally we decided... to drop in last night and I was extremely surprised because it exceeded my expectations. It was family friendly, had indoor andoutdoor seating, food was excellent, and to top it off the staff were amazing. That to me is a 5 star rating and please keep upthe great work! Only thing I was not too happy about was the diet coke (ended up going with iced tea)....please check the lineor taste it. Other than that......excellent choice and glad we finally made the stop to try it. We will be back for sure. Enjoythe photos and try not to get hungry looking at them =) Read more