Reviews for Old Tool Tavern in Randolph, NY
Incredibly friendly and welcoming bar staff and owner, helping with local knowledge and advice on where to go and Amish business... to visit. Brad/Cheech/barkeep was super fun and very on the ball. Food was tasty, modestly portioned, and authentic. Read more
Amazing vibe! Appetizers were so delicious. Definitely found a new favorite spot!
Awesome service. Great prices. Slushies are so tasty! Gotta entertain yourself? Good thing there's a game room!
We got two fish fry sandwich meals and they were amazing haddock slabs of awesomeness. Before they came we were appetized with... some scrumptious zucchini planks. Not wedges. Planks. Read more
Had the soft tacos and hot wings.. Tacos were good. Had the right amount of everything.. Wings were hot and hot. Service, Jess,... was good.. Bathroom was clean.. Read more
Good food and a relaxed country atmosphere. We ate in the restaurant side which was free from TV's and loud music which made it... nice for conversation. As local restaurants go, it's similar to MJ's but is larger and with the chance to find a quieter spot. Price and quality of food is similar to MJs and service was a little faster. Read more
It has a cozy family atmosphere. Good food, drinks for both people who like alcohol & sodas for the kids. Everything is cooked... fresh to order with quality products. There's a game room with crane games to shuffle board bowling to pool & other video games.The interior of the building is hand crafted wood accented with items from days gone by. There's a full service kitchen. Theyalso have a stage for live performances, men - women unisex bathrooms.you have seating options that range from comfortablebooths to high tables & of coarse a serine bar area with comfortable stools. All in all a wonderful dining experience withreasonable prices & courtious staff. I highly recomend this place for fun & meeting place. Large portions that won't break yourwallet..... Read more
Great facility, good food. Terrible for cell phone reception.