Reviews for Random Lake Pizzeria in Random Lake, WI

Ben Huston 1 year ago

Not to often you can give five stars around the board but Random Lake pizzeria does just that!! Amazing atmosphere, amazing... service, AMAZING FOOD! thanks for making it work for our group! The lollipop tree, the arcade game kept the kiddos busy whilethe adults could converse. Great job!!! Customer for life! Read more

Rachel Scherrer 1 year ago

The pizza is so delicious! We drive an hour once a year and always look forward to going. The Chicago Dog pizza is so good. ... It's a must-try. Read more

Jennifer S. 1 year ago

One of my favorite places to eat. The owner Tom is super fun. My favorite is the poppers and antipasto salad. Plus he has fun... specialty pizzas like Chicago style hotdog. You should also try his homemade ice cream! Read more

Vince Morano 1 year ago

Had a very enjoyable time. The calzone was great. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The decorations are unique and add... to the atmosphere here. Reasonable prices, decent beer selection. Read more

Gary Safer 1 year ago

Went for lunch today, had the cheese ring appetizer and a couple pizzas and my wife had salad. Cocktails were good and the... service was above par. We will be back and I highly recommend that that you give them a try, you won't be disappointed... Read more

Will Johnson 1 year ago

TL;DR Food was ok, service was poor at best and employees were sarcastic and mocking when inquiring about order. Food was NOT... served in order of order placement. Was in the area with a party of 10 for an event, and wanted to find a local restaurant toeat dinner at. After reading through several reviews about the food and atmosphere, decided to give it a try. Very nice interiorand quite unique. We were seated quickly, and had drink orders placed relatively quickly. However, after placing our food order,we waited for an hour without any waitstaff checking on our table, and when waitstaff did check on the table asked "What is yourtable waiting on?". After inquiring multiple times about the status of our food, waitstaff began making rude comments to othertables about how our group kept asking about the order status. Meanwhile, a group that was seated an hour after us received ALLof their food by the time we had gotten an appetizer that we received for our wait...which we got BEFORE the appetizer that weordered nearly 2 hours before hand. Waitstaff were drinking on the job as well. After waiting nearly 2 and a half hours wereceived our food. Food was ok, we all ordered pizzas, appeared to be hand made, but were of average quality. Read more

Diane Murley 2 years ago

We only had the home made ice cream, but we loved it. Our waiter was 5 star polite and the decorations are very... entertaining. This restaurant came highly recommended to me. We will definitely go back to try some of their unique pizza combosand delicipus sounding poppers. Read more

Nancy Severn 3 years ago

Delicious thin crust pizza! Next time I am also trying a calzone...they look great!Clean cozy restaurant! Great collection of... decor. Love the bathroom maps "wallpaper". The owner and family are genuine! Read more