Reviews for Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co. in Rapid City, SD

Great Pizza and Garlic Knots. Food was delicious. No complaints about the food. However Pauly's is an order at the counter... (including alcohol) type of place. Customers are given a buzzer, so you also get to pick up your own food. Somehow Pauly's ranout of napkins in the restaurant AND paper towels in the bathrooms. The sinks in the bathroom were the kind you push and waterwas supposed to run for a few seconds. However these turned off immediately. Washing our hands properly was also impossible. As much as I liked the food, the lack of napkins, function sinks, or employees that cared to find a solution will keep me fromcoming back. Read more

We ordered 2 pizzas and got one. When I asked where was our other pizza, I was told by the man that placed our order that he... didn?t ring it up. He said I can order it for you now but it will require you paying again and another 10 minutes or more tomake it. He didn?t even offer a discount for his mistake. He was rude when we did order because we had never been there and thescreens were not working. So when I asked did they have a meat lovers, he looked at me stupidly and pointed to the screens (andrealized they weren?t working). We were not given any plates to eat with and had to use napkins. And they don?t havebreadsticks! What pizza place doesn?t have breadsticks. Very disappointed! Read more

Excellent pizza. Made to order with your choice of crust thickness. I ordered thin and theirs was! Pepperoni pizza was covered... with topping and a nice layer of cheese. TVs for football, and a nice patio for outdoor dining. Limited beer choice, no drafts.No wine. Highly recommend! Read more

Great food and very friendly staff! I visit here frequently when I'm traveling from out of town. The food is always delicious... and the staff so nice! It's amazing how much using my name in conversation after taking my order can make a difference in myexperience! Read more

Amazing. Two pizzas and drinks 24 bucks. Food was amazing and couldn't even finish what I ordered.

We were in rapid city for vacation. Found this place one day for lunch. It was phenomenal. We ended up going here again for... dinner. Prices are great. Friendly staff. Excellent food. Give this place a try!! Read more

Great pizza. Fast service even with pizza made to order. Salads look good too! I ordered rice crispy bars to try also.

This pizza was SO GOOD!!! I?m from Texas and I have never eaten pizza this tasty, every single slice was perfection. The guy in... the register was super nice, I didn?t get his name but he had glasses and was so kind to us the entire time. Hopefully I canvisit sometime again in the future! Try anything and everything, you?ll love it! Read more