Reviews for Cottage Inn Restaurant in Red Creek, NY
I wouldnt go back. Figured id be safe and just get a burger well i was very wrong. Got a little burnt hockey puck. Had floaties... in my water. Prime rib looked great but all in all i think id get wendys lol. Read more
Had a great meal and received great owner interaction. The owner personally checked on our table then decided to sit at our... table and discuss the food and the business. This was a great dinning experience. Read more
The best prime rib around, homemade soups of the day, great staff, tortellinis are delicious, chicken parm is large enough for... 2 meals, a must stop if in the area. Tin can nachos and wings are fabulous. Read more
The food is great and the portions are awesome. We had boiled seafood platter, cheese burger and mild chicken wings. I was very... please with my orders. The staff are friendly and helpful. Read more
Was traveling out of town for work in this area. Really wanted a good meal. Prime rib was excellent?.. tho if to go, order a bit... cooler temp as the wrapping keeps it cooking. That said it was juicy and the grilled onions and mushrooms were tops! Enjoyedevery bite. Baked potato soup - so good. Owner (I assume), noticed me earlier in the day checking out the hours. Ha. Hours aredifferent than you may find on line. Local place. Local patrons. Amazing hospitality to visitors. I still travel to this area.Me and my little bus will be back. Thank you. Read more
We loved the Cottage Inn. It reminds us of a place in NH that we had so many great memories. It has a bar, great service and a... wide variety on the menu of delicious food. It's hard to find a better place to relax and enjoy a wonderful meal. Read more
This restaurant is upstate New York's best kept secret. I'm a retired chef and I always get amazed at this place. Took my... nephew out for his birthday. Our party of five was very satisfied. Everyone was really enjoying this meal. Try the prime rib.Yummy. Peace Read more
Great small town venue offering great food at good prices. Good local bar scene, but a great dining area attached in spearate... dining room. Get there EARLY for the prime rib as they do sell out weekly. Read more