Reviews for Theo's Steaks, Sides & Spirits - St. Michaels in Rehoboth Beach, DE

My wife and I spent a nice weekend at Rehoboth for the Golden Jubilee weekend. Instead of your typically seafood we wanted to... try a new restaurant. I had the 8 oz filet and have to say it was the best steak I ever ate. Our waitress Sarah was verypolite and her service was impeccable. We will be back for dinner next year. Read more

Atmosphere was very nice. They sat us promptly at our reservation time. Waitress came over once we were seated w water and told... us about the specials. We had come specifically for the filet so we didn’t need much time to decide. I asked about sangria andwas told they did not have, but was not offered an alternative. So we ordered the filet and when asked how I’d like it cookedI said I like it pink, so what do you call that? She replied, “medium well”. I said that I don’t think so but as long asit is pink I’ll be happy. My friend ordered the same. It came out strangely fast - maybe 5-7 minutes after we ordered. No onechecked on us for about 15 minutes and at that point we were almost finished with dinner. The steaks were cooked perfectly butthe potato was completely undercooked. When she finally returned to check on us we asked her if they bring bread to the table.She said sometimes. No idea what that meant. She did bring us a bread basket but we declined because we had just finished themeal. We sat for a while and spoke to the nice couple sitting next to us. At this point the restaurant was pretty packed and wedecided we should get up to not hold up the table. We asked for the check, paid and left. Our $57 steak should have been enjoyedand not rushed. Not sure we will be returning. Waitress seemed bored and annoyed. Read more

We went for a delayed anniversary dinner. Everything and everyone were great. The food was cooked to po perfection. I even ate... the brussel sprouts, and I don't like brussel sprouts. Dessert was also very good. So glad we decided to eat there. Read more

This place has gone down hill fast and it’s unfortunate. First time we ate here over a year ago it was fantastic. We... recommended to everyone we knew. Had friends in town so made a reservation over the phone. The next day the manager calls totell me we actually do not have a reservation and she didn’t know why the young man would have given us one or why we receiveda confirmation. No accommodating us even with their mistake. Most recent time (and probably our last) I was served a drink withslimy and rotten mint leaves. The smell of them was like a dingy basement. I watched the bartender notify this same manager andshe shrugged it off like no big deal, make another. Thanks, but i’ll pass. Read more

The atmosphere here us great and the outdoor patio is a great spot to enjoy your meal. They have a vast cocktail menu and a good... wine list. The daily specials were not available when we came which is a bummer but they looked good. We had the tuna tartarwhich I recommend, the Cesar salad was a little depressing (ask for parmesan cheese), for the main course we had the filetmignon and the New York strip which were cooked flawlessly. The mashed potatoes could be whipped a little more in my opinion.Brussle sprouts were very good as well. Overall it was a good experience. Only real complaint is the speed of service throughoutthe whole dinner service (Drinks, ordering, refills, checking in, and getting the bill). Waitress said she had over 20 years ofservice experience (mentioned it after accidentally spilling our drinks) so thats why I'm mentioning it here. 20 years ofservice should be dang near impeccable service. (She was very kind) Don't worry we tipped well. Thank you for the hospitality,we had a good evening with our family. Look forward to coming back and trying the fresh caprese salad. Read more

Great evening with the wife! My wife loves salmon and raved about the flavor & freshness. I had to get the strip which melted in... my mouth and the mashed pots were better than my grandmas! Chocolate mousse to finish our meal. The perfect meal was matchedwith exceptional service! We’ll be back often! Best steak in the state! Read more

I had the worst experience ever at this place. We loved to come here but the waitress and manager were terrible. I ordered the... 32oz Bone In Ribeye medium rare and it came back well done. I was very polite and asked for them to correct it and they weremore than helpful. This is when the bad stuff starts. They never offered to keep my dates dinner warm, instead, she was forcedto eat alone. The entire 40 minutes we waited, neither the waitress or manager came by our table to give an update, refill ourwater, or sodas. I feel they were avoiding us to not give us the opportunity to ask for our check and leave. Once the steakfinally comes out the manager brings it and just goes, “This cooked okay?”. Not I’m sorry for the wait, not anything.While eating, the manager brings us one piece of cake. We didn’t ask for the cake. We didn’t want the cake. Also a $105steak made incorrectly is not quite fixed by a $9 piece of cake. Then when the check comes around (takes about 25 minutesbecause the waitress still has yet to been by the table)…it’s full price. Not a discount. Not even a few bucks off. I’mnot looking for a free meal but like help me out I was more than patient waiting for the meal and was very polite throughout thewhole exchange. When I asked about maybe giving a discount because the meal is so expensive she was like “well we don’t tothat here.” When asked why it took so long “it’s crowded and these people had reservations” meanwhile we hadreservations and were there before most of everyone who was currently dining. It’s unfortunate because we really were excitedto eat at Theos but I do not see myself eating there again because of the poor attitude of its staff. I would tell my friendsthis is must to go eat at. Now I will tell them to go to Houston’s up the road. Much better steak and nicer staff! Read more

Loved it! Nice outdoor & indoor seating. Food & acoholic beverages were really good, great service too. Would definitely stop... by again when in town. Bbq shrimp mildly spicy, tempura shrimp delish & meatloaf entree very good too. Read more