Reviews for Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery in Reynoldsburg, OH
My group is traveling from out of state. Decided to grab some pizza to bring back to our hotel. Nicest employees ever, made us... feel so welcomed. Pizza and cheese bread was great as well! Read more
So sad to have to leave such a low review. Tyler?s has always been a 5 star pizza experience as far as I?m concerned, but my... most recent food experience just a few days ago, the first since 2020, was poor at best. Everything that made Tyler?s so yummyhas changed?no more airy crust or lots of cheese. No flavor. $40 for two pizzas that definitely weren?t any better than LittleCesar?s . I ordered 2 pizzas with double toppings (which means I paid extra?) and they were bare and dry. The crust was thin andoverly chewy as if it wasn?t made correctly, barely any sauce, hardly any toppings. Sigh. I love to support small independentbusinesses, but I won?t be trying Tyler?s again. Read more
I found me a very good pizza place it is it is worth 20 minute drive to get here
We ordered a pizza that was awesome as always. Wasn't planning on getting pastries but they were giving samples of cinnamon... rolls,so I surprised my son and husband with them. Never disappointed thank you. Read more
The first time I tried half Paupers Pie with pep, half 3 Cheese Begeezus. The second time I got a full Pauper's Pie, add... pepperoni, a cheese danish and a chocolate croissant. VERY good pie! The bakery items were TO DIE FOR. Best cheese danish I haveEVER had. I will start going here Tuesdays when their large single toppings are 2 for $22. Read more
I absolutely love this place! We live in Colorado but when I travel out here to see family this is a must stop spot for any type... of baked goods bread pizza croissantsand sweet treats. This place is amazing and Tyler treats it like it's his home kitchen. Ifyou go to Tyler's you will not leave disappointed!!!!! Read more
Stopped in for a little dessert. Had some blueberry bars which were loaded with blueberries, had a lot of an oatmeal taste also.... Also got a cinnamon roll which had a nice frosting on top of crusty pastries that was wrapped around some cinnamon. Yummy. Thisis also a pizza shop. You need to check out both. Great stuff. Read more
Pizza was delicious and service was very friendly. Don't miss pastries. I tried cinnamon crossant and took home blueberry... chocolate chip cookie bars. All were winners. Read more