Reviews for Boniello's in Riverdale, NJ
What happened to Boniello’s? We have eaten here in the past and always enjoyed it. To start the salad had huge chunks of... carrots with iceberg. Dressings did not taste homemade. The pasta dishes were huge portions of overcooked pasta with a fewshrimp swimming in sauce. My grandson had veal Marsala. He said the veal was tough. Disappointing. Read more
Food was delicious. Portions were huge! Our server was very attentive and easy to talk to. He gave recommendations and it turned... out great. The horseradish aioli was to die for! We enjoyed our dinner overall. Read more
You can tell a good restaurant by how busy they are. Boniello's is always busy. People coming and going all the time. The menu... is straight forward Italian including favorites and some special items. Prices are reasonable and the food is fresh withgenerous portions. Friendly service with a pleasing atmosphere makes it a favorite. Read more
My husband and I had dinner there this past Saturday for my birthday. Every staff member was beyond friendly and accommodating... and the food was absolutely delicious!! Can't wait to go back many more times and try everything! Read more
We had a great meal of wings, mussels, the peach salad and a special Teriyaki salad. Stacey was our server and did an excellent... job. All of the young people here were working hard and were all very pleasant. We didn't know that this was a BYOB restaurantand luckily I had a box of several bottles of wine in the car as we are on a road trip and have packed supplies. Greatexperience! Read more
My wife has wanted to go here for quite some time as our friends love the place. I have passed the restaurant lots of times and... always thought it was just another pizza place in a strip mall. Thankfully, I was completely wrong. My wife decided we wouldgive ot a try for her birthday dinner. There wasn't an item on the menu that we all tried that wasn't a quality freshly madedish. They have many menu items that I would expect most pizzerias to have, but then they have great traditional and uniqueappetizer and dinner plates found at purely dine-in only Italian restaurants. The quality of the food explained the ridiculousamount of people on line to pick up to-go orders as nearly every table was full. Restaurant was very clean and staff were great.I believe they may have been a bit understaffed for a Friday evening, but you wouldn't know it as they hustled to make sureeveryone was happy and well served. It's BYOB! Make reservations! Fyi, calamari was attacked by my kids before I could snap apic. Good size portion Read more
Such a wonderful lunch with the girls !! This restaurant has amazing food and a very chill atmosphere! BYOB! Warm bread to start... off the meal with a delicious olive oil dip. I ordered the beet salad ( no beets) && it was fantastic ! I also had the pastacarbonara with chicken! My friends had the pasta carbonara as a main course as well as a nice big salad. You have a choice ofany kind of pasta you’d like for your dish. DELICIOUS FOOD!! We were all stuffed afterwards. If you bring your own wine youget to write your name on the cork and put it on the wall which is a super fun idea. All the waitresses were super sweet,smiling and attentive! Looking forward to going back here or lunch/ dinner or a yummy slice of pizza !!!! Read more
After reading both positive and negative reviews we opted to try it and was very pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food... the service and the atmosphere.. Reasonably price meals good quality and a bright and fresh atmosphere. Read more