Reviews for Agatina's Restaurant in Rochester, NY
My wife and I went there for dinner on a Saturday. When we arrived it was fairly quiet, by the time we left it as very busy. ... The service was the best I have ever received at a restaurant. Dirty plates were quickly taken, water refilled promptly, foodcame in a timely manner, just all around great service! Food was very good, the pasta was cooked perfectly for my liking. Sauce seemed authentic, meatballs were tasty. Fried calamari appetizer definitely not what I was used to, but I enjoyed theirtake on it (Fried, but immersed in aioli sauce). Portion size was excellent, I am a big guy and I couldn't finish my dinner. Overall a very good experience and I'm usually super picky. Read more
We were shocked when we got our food. There are so many great reviews for the restaurant, and the place was packed! We thought... the food would be to die for…until we got it. Looked like all the ingredients had been thrown together in a hurry. The dishtasted like it’d come right out of a can. My wife’s dish was exactly the same. We had both taken away, and we went homehungry. Read more
Went here just yesterday for a bridal shower and the place is really cute. Good amount of parking, the food was awesome... especially the stuffed eggplant rolls were the best I've ever had. The staff was attentive to us the whole time. So from beingat a party there it was a good experience. Read more
Agatinas is a must go for Italian. I e never had an issue making a reservation for the weekends (even last minute) and I find... that’s an issue often for other Italian restaurants. The prices are very affordable and you get a soup and salad with yourpasta or entree which is definitely a selling point. More food for less or same amount you’d spend to have to choose. Asidefrom wonderful service each time I’ve visited, they are very accommodating and can tweak most any request. I look forward toreturning :) Read more
Agatina's was outstanding. The food and service was excellent, and when my wife's order came out with the wrong selection, they... came out and gave us a complimentary right dinner to take home at no charge. I haven't seen that too often in some restaurants.It certainly made our 47 the anniversary very enjoyable. We shall be returning in the future Thank you, Agatina's! Read more
Agatina's Italian resturant is the best. Anyone that wants great Italian food this is the place to go. Great food great service... all around this is our favorite place to dine out. Read more
Top of the line Italian food. We love this place for special dates. Staff there is very professional and attentive to each... table. Reservations are recommended as they don't always accept walk-ins. Read more
I love this place. I have never had a bad meal there. It's not the cheapest place to go to, but the food is good, portions are... more than I can eat. The staff are wonderful. Very nice place. Read more