Reviews for All Star Pizza - Penfield NY in Rochester, NY
Great pizza. Our favorite in the area. Coming from Long Island this has been the best so far. Our driver tonight was awesome,... super friendly. I hope he gets some kudos. I tried to call but it's clearly busy because of Canal Days, but to my dude. You wereawesome. Love this place. Read more
Want to like this place because we have liked the pizza in the past. But we ordered online and when we got home they didn't add... the toppings we asked for, they didn't mark which half was different from the other like we had asked, and while my husband wasthere picking it up, the employees who were working in the back were swearing up a storm, it was very unprofessional. Thereceipt was marked with exactly what we had ordered so I don't know why it went so wrong, but we won't be going back. Read more
Can’t say enough good things about this place. The pizza is by far my favorite and the owner is just so sweet. Great variety... of slices for lunch. If you like thin crust pizza, this will be your favorite place in Rochester. Read more
Was in search of a Penfield area pizza and tired of the local chains. Saw a recommendation for All Star and decided to give them... a try. They do a great, no frills, pepperoni pie. There are lots of options for cook time and crust thickness that I appreciate.No sloppy slices, just a solid thin crust cooked well done and ready in <20 minutes. Total hole in the wall place with a greatsauce: on the sweeter side but with a good zest and thickness Read more
Great place for a slice, good prices and the employees are friendly. The bad reviews are from people who don’t understand that... NY pizza is a completely different style then the doughy garbage we get here in upstate NY. Read more
First time trying a slice @ All Star Pizza and it was fantastic! You can tell that they use high quality ingredients across the ... board. The cheese was super good and all proportions were perfectly even. I will be back to try the wings and get a whole pizzaand I can't wait! Service was also excellent. Read more
All Star Pizza recently catered a company party for us and everything was incredible! Traci worked with us from the beginning to... make a perfect menu for our event and was super helpful with the meal planning. The food was all delicious and everyone reallyenjoyed it! I highly recommend All Star Pizza Read more
Been getting delivery for 3 or 4 years and probably tried everything on the menu. Everything is 4-5 stars, tonight got a chicken... caesar wrap that was great and healthy and an eggplant sub that was very good, service always 5 stars, keep up the good work Read more