Reviews for Fiorella in Rochester, NY

A very unique and pleasant atmosphere. I loved the food and the options available were all very thoughtfully crafted and... designed. So much so that you are actually not allowed to substitute different sauces with different pastas! The chicken cutletis an otherworldly experience. Definitely try it first! I highly recommend this place for any group gathering! The options werewell priced in my opinion. Read more

Loved it here! Food was awesome, got a couple pizzas and they were delicious. The only thing is that it was a bit loud and hard... to hear across the table from me Read more

The best Italian food we have had in a long time. I am a vegetarian and I had several options. Staff very friendly atmosphere... reminded me of a cool, trendy biestro in NYC. Prices reasonable. we had an app, 4 entrees, a bottle of wine and dessert. Billwas very reasonable. We plan on going back soon! Read more

We haven't been to Fiorella in a few years and that's a bad move on our part. We reserved a table outside on a beautiful... evening and had a wonderful meal. We loved it! Started with our go-to appetizer of fried calamari. Yum! My partner had theMafaldine pasta with mushrooms, yellow and zucchini squash, and spinach in a deep flavored sauce. "Magnificent". I have beenwanting to try the Cacio e Pepe and it was amazing. Our server Marco was perfectly attentive without being smothering. Matchedwith a night of perfect weather and bottle of Pinot Grigio... how can you go wrong? Read more

Have gone several times over the years. Incredible consistency at each visit. Very delicious food, nice atmosphere. Friendly... staff. Love going here before shows. Read more

We wanted to dine in but waitress said fully reserved even though it was table outside, so we take out. Pizza was really... delicious as we used to eat in Napoli. Read more

Only downfall is they only have beer/wine and selections are limited but the food is worth it! The meatball appetizer was... amazing and the Margherita pizza is now in my top 5 best ???? in Rochester. Read more

Coming in from the west coast for a wedding, we wanted to go out to try a few Italian places in New York while we were here.... Fortunately for us, we landed on Fiorella's. Fortunately for them, we were hungry! We started with their calamari appetizerwhich featured lightly breaded and crispy calamari mixed with sliced banana peppers served with spicy marinara. Absolutelydelicious- peppers brought an amazing tang to the calamari and the marinara was superb. We then moved to the local tomato,Peach, and Buffalo Mozzarella salad which was honestly one of the finest salads I've ever had. Served over arugula with a fewstrands of basil mixed in for good luck, the salad was simply divine as everything produce-wise is in peak form right now. Thepeaches added incredible sweetness and depth, while the tomato mixture brought every aspect of tomato greatness front andcenter. The Mozzarella felt like sublime excess. The gnocchi special served with crushed San marzano tomatoes, fresh ricottacheese, basil, and Parmigiano reggiano cheese was incredible. Soft, pillowy gnocchi coated perfectly with a rich yet lighttomato sauce that clung to each piece. I will dream about this gnocchi. Our experience was sensational and we highly, highlyrecommend this restaurant. Good luck getting a table if you don't have a reservation on a Friday or Saturday- we strolled in at545 and couldn't get a table until 815. The bar sufficed just fine :-) Read more