Reviews for Jeremiah's Tavern in Rochester, NY
Had a couple beers, was thinking about getting food, something's wrong when chicken wings are probably the most expensive thing... in the menu, and they know that the price is gone. Employee told me that's the biggest complaint. Absolutely ridiculous, yesthey're known for their wings, but they should be considerably less to their sirloin steak tips that are the same price. In fact99% of their menu is cheaper than chicken wings. Chicken wings are supposed to be the thing you sell the cheapest, not the mostexpensive. I know what the markup is, I can assume they're losing a lot of sales and business because of this. Bartender wasfriendly. Read more
Always love the service at this location and the atmosphere. Perfect blend of sit down place and fun bar. Probably my favorite... pub food in Rochester. Read more
We waited 30 mins, and every waitress ignored us. We watched 2 family's get seated and served so we left, terrible service,... terrible experience. I also think it's funny "Jeremiah's" doesn't respond to bad reviews * no care to fix mistakes. Read more
I was starving after a 2 show day at Geva Theatre! Our show ended at 9:30pm. Thank you for being apparently the only place in... Rochester who serves food past 10pm. Ordered bbq wings which were on point! And something I thought was a stacked up burger witha bunch of stuff in it. Totally wasn?t what I was thinking and I really didn?t want it. So I sent it back and got a burgerinstead with cheddar cheese, lettuce tomato, pickles, and mayo, which was perfectly cooked and so juicy! And it came with curlyfries. Our server (Leah) was super accommodating about that. I felt bad to have food get sent back and I do hope someone in thestaff ate it or packed to take home. Thank you Leah for being awesome and caring about me enjoying the food I was having. I?ddefinitely go back and get both items again. Just what I needed after a long day. Pricing was good too! Read more
I got chicken tenders, steak fries, and Mac n cheese to go... The Mac n cheese was too gross to even eat. Looked yummy, but... tasted like it was frozen then microwaved and expired Colby Jack was melted onto it. The chicken was super fried and tastedunsettling. And the fries were too hard, like they were almost raw potato. This was my first time eating there, and the last. Read more
We live nearby and order from here often. Wings are worth the price IMO. Ordered a French dip sandwich and was disappointed in... the small amount of fries that came with the sandwich. Read more
The buffalo wings here are great and so is the sweet sauce too. We had a flat bread pizza which was pretty good! And we also had... some clam chowder that was a great appetizer. The beer was awesome. My new go to place for wings. Read more
I think they might either boil, microwave, or ?air fry? their wings. There?s no reason the wings should be that soft and chewy... when they were ordered extra crispy, even if they?re covered in sauce. If you think these are the best wings in Roc, you mighthave brain damage. Read more