Reviews for Pontillo's Pizzeria West Ridge Rd in Rochester, NY

Best pizza ever! Came here w/ family and we had a great time. The staff was so nice and the food was amazing!

I?ll start by saying this until today has always been my favorite place? However today we picked up our pizza and it wasn?t... cooked. Frozen broccoli stems, canned mushrooms, the heals of tomatoes??? Absolutely disgusting. When I called I got threedifferent people, then the cook who said it was my fault for ordering vegetables? And said he didn?t use fresh mushrooms becauseof germs? Let me know I was annoying, and he was busy basically. It was quite shocking, and we won?t go there again, very sadly.Something is different there. Manager? Owner? Cook?? Idk. But it?s a no for us. Read more

The best pizza in all of Rochester! I grew up down the street and have eaten here every week for many years. Amazing every... single time! The owners are awesome and so is the staff. Highly recommend ???? Read more

Mild wing sauce is weird. Its never enough sauce so today we asked for extra sauce . The mild sauce is like buttery . They gave... the sauce to us on the side and when I think of mild sauce I think the color red Or orange not yellow. Also when they askedfor the phone number I had to repeat it like 10 time repeating one number kept getting confused I said 9 they kept saying 2? Ohyeah and I think the price is different from online it seemed way to expensive today $35 on 10 wings and boneless wings Read more

Excellent pizza. Would recommend the white pizza. The pink is great too. Every time we're in the Rochester area we make sure to... stop by to grab a pizza. Read more

This place was always the goat. Not sure if there's new owners but it was terrible today. Thick tough crust, too much sauce.... Tasted terrible. Not sure what's going on here. ???? Read more

I am from Canada.I have travelled the world over many times and always eat pizza wherever i may be. I have never had a better... Pizza than Pontillos. The crust, sauce and hearty toppings make this place my alltime favorite. If im in Rochester, the is mymust have stop. Read more

The staff is courteous. The pizza is absolutely delicious. Don, know that the pizza you make is art. Perfect proportions and... quality ingredients making a perfect pizza, simple yet somehow transcendent. Read more