Reviews for Atlantic Grill in Rye, NH
We were a party of 4, we sat at a high top in the bar area on Saturday night and it was great. Very clean - our server Anne was... so nice, very personable, she got our drinks right away and made dinner suggestions that were helpful. We had a seafood chowderand roasted tomato’s on pesto for apps with warm rolls and butter. For entrees 2 had the shrimp scampi which they were ravingabout. 1 had the scallops and one had a burger, everything was cooked perfectly and very tasty. To note, 1 in our party has aserious shellfish allergy, and ordered the mashed potato for a side, the Chef came to the table to discuss - above and beyondhere for service! A “custom” starch side was delivered shortly after… For dessert we shared a sundae which was delicious.We had a leisurely meal and will definitely be returning. Great spot!!!! Read more
We had a wonderful dining experience! Anna B our waitress was friendly and attentive. I loved my fresh Rye limeade. I was so... pleased that they offered non alcoholic mixes. It was very refreshing. My fish sandwich was fresh and filling and the bun wasperfectly toasted. . The homemade tarter sauce was delicious. I highly recommend the Atlantic Grille and will be back soon! Read more
Excelente food, mussels were in a tasty wine broth. Our Waitress was fenomenal It was an outstanding experience
Atlantic Grill is a jewel! Superb cuisine, excellent service! 5 of us showed up on a busy Sunday, no tables available on line. ... In no time at all staff set up a table on the patio. Within minutes we were exploring the menu and enjoying our cocktails. Fresh is the word! I've been a patron for years and it just keeps me coming back! You will enjoy your time here! Read more
Enjoyed a lovely lunch on a rainy Sunday at the Atlantic Grill. Able to make reservations, was seated in an area right by a... beautiful gas fireplace. Tables are socially distanced. Our waitstaff was very attentive. Food was great. Beer-battered fish wascrisp and tender, served with crispy fries. Hubby got Caesar salad with croutons that were out of this world. Clam chowder wasgood as well. Oh, I almost forgot! Yummy Bloody Marys. Look forward to coming back in the summer for the outdoor seating. Read more
The food used good ingredients, was cooked perfectly, but it was noticeably under-seasoned and priced at about $50 per person... for dinner with apps. Having loved the Thistle Pig, I know Chef Ben can (and almost always does) do better. I suspect staffshortages in the kitchen affected performance. It was still a good meal, but not memorable, and we needed to salt almosteverything that came out of the kitchen to achieve the great flavors we expected. Read more
Went here for the first time a couple months ago and the food was delicious! The restaurant was so cute and our waitress was... friendly. My only complaint is their mocktail for the Moscow mule was not good in the slightest. It was so watered down ittasted like ginger water with no lime or carbonation. Read more
The food was good, but not great. Especially considering the price. The mixed drinks were okay, we ended all having regular ones... instead. The fish was tasty, but the amount was laughable if I'm being honest. The broccolini was steamed and useasoned. Themash potato tasted good, but again, wasn't mind blowing. My wife had scallops, but they were rubbery. For 42$ a plate, I kindawas hoping for more food, or at least be mind blown by the flavor. The ambiance was nice, however. Read more