Reviews for Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out in Sag Harbor, NY

Always wonderful. Cozy, outstanding food quality ans taste. Owner and staff are always welcoming and friendly. Never a... disappointment! Read more

Have not had pizza here in years but remember it as being pretty good. This time I was shocked how bad it was. Very little... sauce and flavor. Dough was tough and bready. The toppings covered 3/4 of the pie. Requested well done and saw a very whitecrust. Maybe it was an off night but it was disappointing. Not sure we'll try again. Read more

The waitress was exceptional. Friendly and efficient, anticipating our every need. The food was scrumptious. The calamari were... among the best I have had. The sea bass with capers was excellent. We order sandwiches from here but this dinner was great. Read more

Wow! This is the best Italian food I’ve had on Long Island! Everything we ordered reminded me of the meals my Italian great... aunts and my grandmother would cook. So delicious and authentic. ???????? The meatballs and the rigatoni Bolognese were justperfect. The mussels in white wine were fresh and delicious, as were the sautéed mushrooms and broccoli rabe. We can’t waitto return for another meal! Read more

Home of the best garlic knots on the planet. This place is a must stop when driving into Sag Harbor.

Been here twice. Once to dine in and once for take out. Service is excellent and great little spot with good food. ???? The... manager/server/owner. .not sure his exact position is amazing! I think his name is Luigi. Always kind and prompt with greetings& service. Always a pleasure to stop by and satisfied w every visit so far! The space is not too large so if you have a biggerparty, best to make reservations! Read more

New Years Eve…… we placed a takeout order. My husband picked up the order, take out area was very busy. The young lady... wished my husband happy new year, and he told her it was his birthday too. When we unpacked the food at home, we saw a dish wasomitted. My husband drove back to restaurant, where our correct dish was waiting. They apologized profusely, the waitstaff allsang happy birthday to my husband, and presented him with a bottle of wonderful Chianti!!!! With so many orders coming in andgoing out, I still can’t believe the young lady remembered my husbands birthday!!! What a gracious thing to do!! We eat herevery often, because their food is outstanding!!!! Best eggplant parmigiana ever!!!! Read more

Amazing Italian restaurant! The food and staff were wonderful. The portion size is great. I had a tough time finishing my... half-plate order of pasta. The prices were very fair, especially since you get so much. Will definitely go back again! Also, thecalamari was AMAZING! Read more