Reviews for M.J. Dowling's in Sag Harbor, NY
Friendly staff. Underwhelming food. Ordered the grilled shrimp. It was a bad mixture of frozen shrimp with too much pepper. I... would recommend this place for calm vibes. I would recommend against the food. Read more
Twice they’ve missed items for Uber Eats. This time they missed them when I called — 8 times — they hung up on me when... they even answered. The owner should know the employees hang up on customers. My nephew tried calling and they did the samething — picked up and click. Awful. Food mediocre when you can get it. Don’t bother. Read more
Wonderful as always. We come here every summer with the family. Shame the games room is gone but have heard the pizzas are... fantastic. We didn’t have them this time but will try next for sure. Love that each day has a specials. Shrimp night is myfavourite. Kids love the food and it’s always so great whatever we have. Outside seating was lovely and staff are veryattentive and friendly. Read more
I ordered a pizza something simple. Delivery. I ended up with nothing. I called. They said it was doordash responsibility. ... My money was taken out of my bank account. I got nothing. And no one would take responsibility for it. So I don't reccomendit. Read more
I placed an order with them through Uber eats. I ordered a corn, shrimp and chorizo quesadilla. When it arrived it look... delicious, but when I took a bite of the quesadilla I immediately had to spit it out. The shrimp was bitter and tasted old. Ithrew out the whole thing and I paid $20 for the plate. Very dissatisfied. Read more
Eddie is hands down the best bartender on the East End this Century. The TVs, the accessibility of the place, ample parking, you... just gotta see it to believe it- and what do you want? Fries, Pizza? How do you like your crust? Thin? Thick? Your choice, as isNew York Strip, Prime Ribs, Filet Mignon and an Open Mike Night Wednesdays... Read more
Wonderful spot with excellent food and amazing staff. Got a ribeye which was huge and delicious and my sister got the burger... and fries (which were some of the best fries I've ever had). Garrett our bartender was phenomenal with wonderful conversationand attentive to our needs. Would definitely come back to try out the rest of their menu! Read more
The staff were great. The food was mostly good to great. Very happy over all. I will go back.