Reviews for Tutto Il Giorno South in Sag Harbor, NY
My husband and I came here for our anniversary dinner and had an incredible experience! We enjoyed our authentic Italian meal.... The ravioli were some of the best we have ever had in our lives. We were also given complementary champagne for the occasion. Wecannot wait to go there again and enjoy some of the other items on the menu. Read more
Probably one of the prettiest restaurants in the Hamptons. With a gorgeous patio and indoor space, decorated in a stunning beach... chic decor, this is the place to see and be seen in the Hamptons. The food is great most of the time (recently I had a butternutsquash soup for my appetizer that was tasteless), but most often than not, the food is on point. During the high season, youcannot get a table without a reservation, so plan to wait over 2 hours if you do a walk-in (sometimes they won’t even be ableto accommodate you). The wine list is true to Hampton prices, so don’t be shocked to pay $28 for a glass of wine, and upwardsof $130 for the most inexpensive bottle. They usually have special additions to the menu, and they are worth trying! Read more
What an amazing time. From the hostess, to the servers to the bartenders - they were all great. But the GM, Nick, was pretty... much one of the most exceptional people I have ever met or been taken care of at a restaurant in my life. I own a Bar/restaurantin the city and have been in the biz for over 20 years, and this is a person and place I had to write about. So bravo. And weeven saw Paul McCartney right next to us at the bar. Pretty cool. Read more
Great vibes. The cocktails cost as much as normal dinner for two but everything is great, go for the pastas.
We were in Sag Harbor on a moderately cold March afternoon and walked by this place which was yet to open at around 3 pm. After... getting a drink from a near by bar, we showed up again at 3:45 and their team was kind enough to get seating in a wonderfullysetup outdoor area. They noticed we were all cold, and so was our 2 year old, and their super helpful and friendly staff put 4outdoor heaters in 4 corners for us so we could enjoy our time here. And what a fabulous experience we had. Their entire team isabsolutely amazing and they mixed some powerful and tasty cocktails for our group. We had just come back from lunch, so weren'tthat hungry, but everytime we passed the kitchen the aroma from food was just making us a but hungry which made us order theirRisotto ($35) and Tortelli ($34) which our server suggested. Now, in my opinion, Indian's are the biggest critiques of Italianfood and often times find it bland, thanks to our "sometimes" overpowering, yet flavorful spices, so the expectation was quitelow - but were we surprised when presented with one of the most flavorful and delicious Italian food we've ever had! We wererunning late for a dinner reservation, which we couldn't cancel at the last minute, else this was an absolute perfect place towine and dine! This place is bookmarked as one of our favorites and special thanks to the super friendly team at Tutto for awonderful evening filled with excellent ambiance, food, and service. Will definitely visit again! Read more
Are you really in the Hamptons if you don't get Tutto il Giorno?! Definitely the spot to go if you want a delicious filling... meal. I honestly had this about 5-6 times last summer. It's still on my mind. I cannot wait to go back Read more
It is a wonderful dining space, with knowledgeable affable staff. The food was on time and perfectly prepared. The Cioppino was... very good but the veal chop was perfect. Notable. Great cut, perfectly prepared. The Budino and Cappucino were awesome. I’llbe back. ???????????????? Read more
When we got to Sag Harbor we immediately noticed this restaurant and decided to try it. Inside it was very cozy and relaxing. ... However, the waitress made a few remarks to us that made us feel very uncomfortable. Drinks were overpriced. Three glasses ofwine, and two cocktails came to over $200. And although we ordered a lot of food, nothing was offered to us on the house. Also, the waitress never gave us bread. However, the food was very good. Read more