Reviews for Theo's Steaks, Sides & Spirits - St. Michaels in St Michaels, MD

We were seated by a table of 10 that were extremely loud, there were many open tables but figured they were for other... reservations. The server told us she was really really busy and proceeded to have us there for almost 2 hours and 45 minutesfood was just okay. My husband and I felt were extremely disappointed . I would not recommend Read more

1. Our server Charmaine was really sweet. We enjoyed her company. 2. The Wedge was crisp and excellent 3. The crab cake was very... good. Nicely seasoned but not overdone. 3. Ahi tuna was cooked perfectly rare. I could have used another couple pieces but notthe end of the world. I would go back. Read more

Theo's was an amazing experience from start to finish. We were so impressed with the food, presentation, ambiance, and service.... Our server, Chance, was awesome and provided great food and wine recommendations. Theo's far exceeded our expectations and wewill definitely be back! FYI, Theo's was so good in all aspects that, when we went to DC a few days later, we were veryunderwhelmed by the nationally acclaimed Bourbon Steak at the Four Seasons. Read more

The steaks are very good here, but I found the food in general overpriced. The vegetable selection is scanty, and the interior... is oddly dark, even for restaurant ambiance. I asked the server to give me my au poivre sauce to take home w/my leftovers, andit was left out, which as it costs an extra few dollars, made me a bit cranky. Read more

Truly one of the best meals I've had in some time. BBQ Shrimp, red snapper, tuna steak were all out of this world tasty. ... Atmosphere was great, service was friendly and knowledgeable of the food and wine, wine was reasonable and good choices. Read more

I have to think this place is highly overrated based on our experience with takeout tonight. Ordered two burgers, medium rare,... with added cheese. Didn't get cheese on either burger. Got very rare burgers, and overcooked, dried out fries. All of it wasunder-seasoned. With so many other better places in town to eat, I'm not sure how this place gets away with its exorbitantprices. Not worth it. Read more

The food is fantastic and the service even better. Great ambiance, cozy bar setting, and very friendly and attentive employees.... Shout out to Audrey and Lacey for a wonderful customer experience!!! Read more

Cannot say enough about our wonderful experience! We were seated quickly and not rushed. Our server Shannon was friendly,... professional and knowledgeable. The oysters were fresh and fat. Our steaks were perfect and the best we've ever had! Theambience was beautiful. We will be back! Read more