Reviews for Straight From New York Pizza in Salem, OR

Great place. Last place I got to eat with my true love.

Employees are too incompetent to take phone orders actually make the pizzas and have them ready. They take no responsibility and... blame the computer and have an I don't care attitude. I've ordered pizzas from here usually twice a week for years but am fed upwith the lack of professionalism and management. They're just too stupid. Read more

Pizza is always good. They do not have whole peperoncino?s though! If the owner sees this: please consider getting those for the... customers. Thank you. Read more

Not sure what happened, been ordering here for over two years and it was always excellent. The last two deliveries were cold and... tasted like chuck e cheese pizza. Are they under new ownership? Sorry but it's not good anymore and we will not be orderingagain. Also started giving subsitutes on drinks and not calling to ask if that was ok. Read more

I imagine it must be stressful to receive calls from customers (like me) asking when they can expect their delivery to arrive,... one hour after ordering....then two hours after ordering. This has happened both times I tried delivery. The first time ithappened, they had obviously forgotten about my order and said something like the delivery guy had it, but they'll make a newone incase he doesn't deliver it. Umm...very confusing. Just don't risk delivery, especially if you have hungry kids at homeasking when the food will be there. This location needs to make some serious changes in how they handle their deliveries. Bothtimes it's taken two hours for a single cheese pizza. Read more

Ordered a whole pizza at the store. Told it would take 25 minutes. It took over an hour and it was a weeknight. Also ordered a... salad and the only made it after I asked about it after 45 minutes. The pat answer is, it will take 8 more minutes. Ha! Pizzais decent. I'd advise you only drop in and order a pre-made slice or two and bail. The customer service is HORRIBLE. I saw themmake multiple people wait for their pick up orders. Again, 8 minutes. Yeah, right. Read more

Straight From New York Pizza has awesome pizza! Me and my girlfriend both hot the slice and salad combo. Katy also got a can... of rose wine and said it was very tasty. The salad bowl was amazing! The service was excellent. Highly recommended when yourin Salem Oregon! Read more

The pizza was great! Never been to New York before so I wouldn?t know if it actually tastes like New York.