Reviews for Straight From New York Pizza (Downtown Salem) in Salem, OR

Friendly service, pizza was good, they had a deal going on, I think it was happy hour.

I was recently visiting Salem the other day and stumbled across this restuarant on my walk downtown. The pizza was phenomenal... and reminded me of Spicy Pie back in North Dakota. The pizza was fresh, great thin crust, and very reasonably priced. My sliceof pizza was only $3! The staff was also very nice and friendly. Read more

Keeps it humble, keeps it simple, and it keeps me coming back. Their appeal is punctuated by their friendliness. Delicious, thin... and plentiful pizza - there isn't a whole lot that needs to be explained. You pick your options. As of this writing, theyaccommodate indoor and outdoor seating, however limited and "cozy" - not "cramped," but room enough to enjoy a quick meal and apiece of calm from an otherwise stressful and busy world, if only for a few bites. Their by-the-slice pizza keeps people comingback through their doors, and - from personal experience - their delivery is also a delicious draw. As a frequent enjoyer, Iprefer their approach over most other bigger players in town. Their menu caters to all appetites and sensibilities. But it'sthe down-to-earth quality that keeps me coming back. 10/10, this pizzeria is doing it right. Read more

Talk about a large pizza. The sauce is great the dough is not heavy. Prices are fair my son loves this pizza. It's a great place... to dine in as well several selections of pizza and a few beer selections. Read more

Decent pizza. Appearance is awesome, good crust and decent base. Not worth $17 for a 14 inch pizza. That should be the price for... a 16 to 18 inch pizza. Having said that?good luck finding a fair pizza price within the Salem area. At this spot, they charge $4for one slice!!! Read more

Great place to pop in and grab a slice of pizza. My son and I found a booth and enjoyed the large pizza voices, he got plain... cheese and I had the Marguerite. Very tasty. The tip of my sons pizza broke off and fell to the floor. He got a second slice forfree. I would say check this place out the next time your craving for some pizza. Read more

The pizza was mediocre and felt pretty dry. I would have maybe given three stars, but part of my order was done incorrectly.... When I called in the order, I asked for a dozen chicken wings, half with bbq sauce and half just plain. I made it very clear Idid not want buffalo sauce (since I can?t handle spicy food very well) and the receipt even said 6 plain wings; instead, I gotbuffalo sauce. That seems like an easily preventable mistake. The wing meat was quite good, actually, but after the ones withthe buffalo sauce my lips were numb, eyes watery, and who knows how my lower half will do later. Also, either the prices on thewebsite are wrong or I was overcharged. Online it says the large Combination pizza is $29 and a dozen wings are $10 (I wascharged $30 and $12, respectively). Read more

This was our first time trying (went to the location on Liberty), and honestly first impression of the pizza was mediocre - like... pizza from a mall. Bottom of pizza was very slightly black so it left a bit of a burnt taste in my mouth, and the crust was sohard so it made it easy to skip the extra carbs there. I'd get a giant breadstick again though if I crave a soft, doughy breadthat reminds me of a cinnamon roll. Read more