Reviews for Antioch Pizza Shop - Paddock Lake, WI in Salem, WI
We are new to the area and were looking for a new place for pizza. 1st time we went (a month or so ago) our order was wrong and... toppings were scant and looked like they were just tossed on the pizza. We ordered for the first pizza cheese, sausage, andonion. We received our pizza with those toppings plus mushrooms. We ordered a second pizza with pepperoni and cheese. Bothpizzas were completely full on the bottom of black remnants from the pizza oven obviously not being clean. Waste of money as myson wouldn?t eat his pizza. Food was hardly warm and we live five minutes away. Fast forward to yesterday 10/20 we thought wewould give them a second chance. We ordered the two slice special and the steak sandwich special with everything. We orderedsausage thin and sausage pan for our slices and the thin had clearly been there for awhile, as it was dry, tasteless, and lackedsauce. The pan sausage had a ton of cheese but hardly any crust and what was there was mushy. Our steak sandwich was orderedwith everything, which according to the website has garlic bread, onion, mozzarella cheese. What we got was an old, fatty pieceof steak with no flavor the bread had a garlic spread on it but was not toasted at all! There was nothing on it no cheese and noonions and again all of our food was just slightly warm. The only reason I gave them two stars was the girl checking is out wasvery nice. Two visits both times orders were wrong, hardly warm, and food was definitely not up to par. Sadly we have to keepsearching for a pizza place and won?t be back. Read more
Called and ordered one 16 inch pizza at 405 was told 25 or 30 minutes dropped my wife off at Walgreens got there to pick my... pizza up at 430 and was told they didn't start making it and would be 30 more minutes I'm just shocked that they acted like itwas no big deal. Now it gets better I finally get it home go to eat it and it's not remotely cooked so we have it in the oven???????????????????????? Read more
Yummy Yummy Yummy. I love the hot & ready pizza slices. No wait. The chicken is good. The honey bbq sauce tastes amazing. Pure... deliciousness. The icecream is omg!!! I tried m&m with oreo (never had it b4) So good ???? ???? I plan on returning soon eventhough it is a drive. It's so worth it. Read more
As a local, I have eaten takeout many times from here since moving here in early 2021. Sometime over the past number of months,... I've noticed a significant decrease in the amount of pizza sauce on their thin crust pizzas, causing me to lower to 2 stars from5. It takes away from taste and you feel like you might as well be eating cheesy bread. I have ran over to the local grocerystore to grab a jar of prego pizza sauce due to low pizza sauce on pizza. I have notified them before over the phone about thepizza sauce. This week I had 2 slices of deep dish pizza that also were low on sauce. If it continues, I will unfortunatelydiscontinue coming here for pizza. Read more
From out of town and choose this pizza place , a little sauce but good kids ate it up . The lady on the phone was nice !
This is a great place for good tavern style Chicago pizza. Great crispy thin crust, nice sauce, and just the right mix of cheese... and toppings. They have a great lunch special for two slices and a drink. Highly recommended. Read more
2 slices 1 beverage $7, okay. 2 slices stacked on top of each other, not okay. Ate it anyhow as I was in a rush. ... Owners/Managers, you unintelligently set up these kids with the .06 cent flimsy economy 9? paper plates. This is on you. Atleast Use paper plates where two slices fit. Or buy the 9 1/2? - 10? plastic plates for dine-in customers and wash dishes. You?ll save in the long run. Good luck. Read more
Love this place. The pizza deals are fantastic! I recently ordered the salad version and LOVED it. My only real gripe is that... the salad comes out in a Styrofoam takeaway box. I really wish it was something recyclable. It really deturs me from coming moreoften Read more