Reviews for Humphreys Restaurant in San Diego, CA

Have only eaten here as part of concert ticket packages but have four years of experience to rate them on. I can say my ratings... would be the same as four years ago. They're consistently above average. We always enjoy our meal and drinks with friendlyservice, but not feeling worth the fifth star. Read more

Food and cocktails were great. The venue is beautiful with huge windows overlooking the docks and up into the point Loma hills. ... Old school elegance with big white overstuffed chairs to dine on. The steak was tender and perfectly cooked. Read more

View was nice, food was unfortunately not seasoned. Ordered eggs Benedict. The poached egg was way over cooked, almost like a... boiled egg. The hasbrowns needed salt, actually everything needed salt. Read more

Love this place with it's great views, live music, food and an amazing staff

Humphrey's is a fashionable, fine dining restaurant in a very good area along San Diego Bay. The restaurant appears... well-appointed, the staff are attentive and friendly, and the menu is diverse and full of fresh seafood choices. We enjoyed bothappetizers and main courses -- ranging from lobster risotto and pork chops to crab cakes and a beautiful scallop appetizer. Weenjoyed our time here and plan to return. Read more

Solid choice on Shelter Island, what you'd expect for fine dining. The cuisine is a little derivative, they aren't driving the... trends or producing anything unique or innovative. Good flavorful food, a little overpriced for what you get. Read more

Well, I was really expecting a better experience at Humphrey's. The restaurant is situated next to a bar that offers live music.... That's a raucous place all on its own and the sound of the music also carries over into the restaurant a bit. On a positivenote, the restaurant is attractive, the staff are attentive and friendly, and the view out of the large windows into the marinais very nice. However, the food service was a bit uneven. The pork chop dish was good, but only after being sent back to ensurethe pork was cooked through completely. The lobster risotto was flavorless and bland. There was also a lack of lobster, but thebiggest problem was the overall lack of flavor. By comparison, the scallop and crab cakes appetizers were quite delicious.However, there was only one - yes, one(!) -- scallop in the scallop dish. Please....why???? There was also only one crab cake,but that was at least larger. So, gang in the kitchen, please focus a bit more on the menu dishes and get them out perfect thefirst time. Also consider upsizing some of the serving sizes for the appetizers. If you do that, then this review will jump to a5-star review right away. Read more

Great place to go see music, drink and eat some fantastic food. Prices are reasonable. Small venue. You get a great view... anywhere you sit in there for seeing live music. One of my favorites places. Read more