Reviews for Mustafio's Pizza in San Francisco, CA
Great pizza place! Went in on a whim and turned out to be one of the best pizza slices I\'ve ever had! Super creamy cheese... without being greasy and crunchy crust, very fresh toppings. Definitely recommend if you\'re in the area, open late so perfectfor bar hopping! Read more
Chicken pesto slice is amazing and the slices are huge! Excellent customer service as well. A delightful experience here. ... Open late hours as well. Read more
I always enjoy finding a new Slice House around the country or even around the world. I had no idea how many San Francisco had... and glad this was one of my first ones to discover on this trip as it\'s pizza by the slice with a premium touch. Great serviceand amazing Pizza. Not your ordinary slice house but a place you can get quality pie Read more
Is this the best pizza i have ever tasted?\nYes it is!\nI went when i was vegetarian and the cheese slice it was amazing. Now... that I’m vegan, Shake prepare it without cheese, with the ingredients that I want.\nDon’t leave SF without taste it! Read more
OMG??????????????????\nSuper Yummy..... Stumbled across this place during work hours, what caught my attention was the square... slices ( I thought, \" how cute\")\nI stepped inside and was pleased to learn their pepperoni is Beef, ( I Dont eatswine/pork)\nThe Pizza was SO delicious, I thought next time I\'m in the area, I\'ll get a whole pie to take home. Well I didand the whole family enjoyed the heck out of it .... This will be my new go to spot here in the city????????????????????????? Read more
Based on the reviews, I wanted to like this place, but my experience was less than ideal. Maybe it was the time that I came, but... I won\'t be coming back.\n\nI walked in and ordered a sandwich and a small salad to go. The guy at the counter said it would be20 minutes, which was fine, as food made to order is a lot better than stuff that\'s been under a heat lamp. The time it took toactually get it was enough to walk a block and a half, buy a drink from a convenience store, come back, and still wait another10+ minutes. That in and of itself wouldn\'t have been much of an issue, ordinarily. But...\n\nWhile I was waiting, I noticedthat the guy making my and others\' orders touched, by my count, at least 5 different surfaces (food, earbuds that were in hisears, oven handles, plastic bags, knife handle) with no gloves and without ever washing his hands. But I was ravenous and in nomood to argue with anyone. I hope I don\'t get salmonella, E. coli, or hepatitis.\n\nAs for my order itself, the salad was good.The sandwich, on the other hand, was overcooked-to-burnt. Maybe 2/3 of it was edible; the last third was hard and tastedcharred.\n\nIf nothing else, it was a reminder that it\'s cheaper and safer to cook than it is to go out. Before tip, it was$16.36 for 2/3 of an overcooked sandwich and a small salad with a packet of no-fat dressing (no choice, apparently). Read more
Delicious pizza, fresh & tasty, open late. Couple tables inside for a quick bite to eat. Reasonable prices, no complaints.
Nasty greasy pizza and the greedy guy always charge you extra $1 for ranch. AVOID