Reviews for New York Pizza Palo Alto in San Mateo, CA
Simply amazing pizza! The customer service is down to earth and friendly. The pizza crust is perfect. Will definitely return.
Great Pizza! The cheesesteak is excellent. The salads are huge; easily big enough for two. Nice, family owned local business.
Great pizza and customer service. They accidentally sent me the wrong pizza (pepperoni and ham kong size pizza) instead of a... PINEAPPLE and ham kong. They immediately rectified the situation by sending a replacement at no extra cost and even let me keepthe original pizza. Highly recommend. Read more
The Marriott gave me their menu. I ordered a delivery pepperoni and mushroom pizza and a Greek salad with Italian dressing.... Y’all- this was delicious pizza. The dough is super good. I’m visiting from the the southeast and this pizza is great. TheGreek salad was fresh and big. The cucumbers, tomatoes etc were fantastic. It should be given that salads are fresh, but in myexperience it’s not! Highly recommend! Read more
Very friendly staff, breadsticks were amazing! Pizza slices are huge couldn’t even finish one. Only thing I didn’t care for... was extra crispy edges but the pizza was very good. Would definitely recommend Read more
Far away from being N.Y style pizza..take it from a N.J girl who came here excited about getting actual pizza but left pretty... disappointed. The pizza is like the ones you Can make at home, you can see the easy bake holes in the dough. I'm guessing it'scalled this way because if its thin style but nothing else. If you do decide to go to this place [ it's pretty small inside]take out is best. The deal they have seems to be good but in reality it isn't. I got the salad which was lettuce and a bunch ofgreen peppers and chives for some reason but what I hated about it was that the lettuce is the part of the middle which is noleaf at all. The meatball sub wasn't half bad! But the sauce was absolutely cold. Anyways I will not come here again. Read more
THINK BIG! He slices are huge and the King Kong pizza is massive! The crust is the perfect combination of crispy, and chewy.... The marinara sauce is straight from a New York kitchen! And they load the pizza with fresh toppings. I LOVE theCombination: it has the perfect taste. And they make very savory Ranch dip sauce that I love to always enjoy. don't forgetto also try their chicken wings. Super crispy and meaty! Read more
Pizza was great, guy named Billy gave me some of the best customer service I've seen in a while. Had a complicated order, he got... everything correct without a single topping missed. Read more