Reviews for Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream in Sanibel, FL

My husband and I took our two young daughters here for dessert. We all enjoyed it a lot. There wasn?t a weird smell like some... mentioned in previous reviews so the owners must have addressed that. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The ice cream andgelato was delicious. Read more

Great ice cream. Thought prices were a bit high until we got our ice cream and the portions were great!! Great value!

Large portions. Good flavors. Prices are decent, and what you'd expect for an island destination. Half their selection is gelato... or sherbet, so they could probably offer some additional choices of ice cream. Good place to go for ice cream though. I'd goback. Read more

Very good ice cream. Veteran place with home made ice cream, including some specialty flavors. Our entire family (couple + 3... kids) enjoyed the ice cream immensely. This place is highly recommended to stop at Sanibel Island. Read more

Great service. Very good over cream. Large portions. Make sure you check the size/quantity before you order. Was surprised how... large the Brownie sundae was. Read more

we love coming in here after a hot day out at the beach. The best shakes and assortment of ice cream flavors in all of Sanibel.... Definitely a must stop for all tourists and locals alike Read more

Tons of ice cream flavors to choose from, gelato, sorbet, and sherbet too! The portions are generous. Definitely an island... favorite, so prepare for it to be busy around usual dessert timing. Read more

A lot more spacious inside, and they still have all the good ice cream. Prices are reasonable. I could get a 3 scoop cone for... $5.45 Read more