Reviews for Butera's in Sayville, NY
Really enjoyed our visit. The food was on point, and the service lovely. Owner stopped by to check that everything was to our... liking ????????. Read more
Went for a funeral lunch. Food was delicious but waitress forgot to bring mine, and didn't get until everyone else was done... eating (pasta Primavera) not a difficult dish to make. The manager was very apologetic, And everything was OK until waitressdecided to forget my cappuccino also.. Staff needs some training.. Food was delicious Read more
Had an excellent lunch of blackened sea scallops over a warm bed of greens and cannelloni beans expertly prepared.
Amazing lunch with huge portions at an affordable price! We got the grilled shrimp salad, mushroom asparagus and grilled chicken... salad, and rigatoni alla rosa. The salad was perfectly dressed! The shrimp was slightly over cooked but till enjoyable. It alsohad 2 slices of bread that were really really hard which is I think their version of a crouton. We did ask for bread and it camewith some olive oil. Definitely coming back for more affordable and delicious meal options! FYI - Costco sells gift cards hereat a cheaper price! Read more
It was a nice place for dinner... I liked the fact that they catered to both family style as well as smaller regular meals. The... employees were friendly, courteous and very helpful. Read more
Sorry Buteras - I wish I could give you more stars. My second time here - I had the steak pizaola the first time and was... underwhelmed at the quality of the steak -- though the accompanying onions, peppers and sauce were tasty. Second time I decidedto try it again and it was honestly tough as old boots. I should have sent it back, but didn't want to ruin the evening withthe family by complaining. Giving the place 3 stars because I didn't give them the opportunity to fix it -- if you go here,stick to the pasta dishes and stay away from the steak - they seem to consistently use lesser quality cuts. Prices are prettyhigh too - expect $90 per couple for salad, app and dessert. Read more
I am just awed by this amazing restaurant. Jerry, Paul, Denise and the rest of the staff were so accommodating. Another... restaurant canceled my reservation when I was conducting a Fundraiser for a local family. With two days notice I had to findanother venue.. The Shrimp Francese was so yummy and of course the tartufo. The staff was so friendly and they all worked sowell together. A really nice, warm, family atmosphere. Thank you. ? Read more
What a lovely dining experience. The food was absolutely creative and delicious and copious amounts were served. If you want to... take your family out and impress your mother-in-law go to Butera's. Read more