Reviews for Eastchester Fish Gourmet Restaurant in Scarsdale, NY

Go Fish - is a hidden gem that I tried towhilst waiting for my prescription to be filled at CVS. I had the Shrimp Po-boy and... sweet potato fries. The Sandwich was beyond delicious as well as the fries. Will be sending friends and family here. Qualityfood at is best and reasonably priced!! Read more

We have been coming to Eastchester Fish for 15-years or more, it’s been our favorite for seafood. Over the last few visits... there has been a noticeable overall decline. Last night was our final visit. Seems 90% of the staff are new and poorly trained,my family and I felt we were in a diner. The food was slung on the table and server off to the next. We ordered several types ofoysters, they were tossed on the table and server gone like a drive by. Food used to be spectacular, it was mediocre at best.Fish ill prepared, sauce watered down. Disengaged manager, chatting with the staff at the podium acting quite unprofessional.Sad to see it. Maybe there was a change in ownership? Read more

While we used to eat at Eastchester Fish frequently, we hadn’t eaten there as a result of the pandemic for almost two years.... I’m happy to report that if it’s possible, the restaurant is providing even better meals and service than ever! And while itused to be tough to get reservations, now they use RESY and it’s much easier to reserve in advance! We had a wonderfulwaitress and a fantastic dinner! Read more

What a horrible experience. My husband took me here for dinner last Saturday evening. It was for my Mother's Day dinner my... husband works for NY corrections my son NYPD both had to work on Mother's Day so my hubby wanted to treat me. Ok we are abiracial couple married 23 years this restaurant treated us like I was my husband's lady of the night. Unreal! No attention todetails waitress completely ignored us and my lobster was overcooked 2x left went home without having my dinner. Worseexperience ever. Will not recommend or return. Read more

Amazing food and service. Highly recommend trying the crispy wild octopus ????

An experience beyond any other. The food, service and attention to detail are a 10++. Jazz was playing in the background as we... were eating which just added to the night. Dont hesitate to dine here. Your mind and stomach will thank you. Read more

Top-notch seafood restaurant. The fish is fresh and wild caught for the most part. The service is impeccable. Desserts are... delicious! Highly recommend this place. Read more

Great seafood spot in Eastchester. Wasn't too loud for our date night. Service was good, very attentive. Dishes were fresh. ... Loved the fried octopus, salmon over spinach risotto and coconut flan. Not too pricey either. Will recommend to friends. Read more