Reviews for Caruso's of Schaefferstown in Schaefferstown, PA

Stopped here for first time while visiting in the area. We ordered a specialty 4 Cheese Pizza. It was fantastic. Tons of cheese... and great taste. Friendly service. Clean restaurant and restroom. Huge menu. Absolutely would return here again. Read more

Absolutely loved their pizza. Big menu but their pizza is really solid. I felt the buffalo chicken really stood out to me. I'm... also in love with the Chipotle Cheesesteak, though it's a little too pricey for a college student to order on the reg Read more

Me and my GF , often go here for great Italian cooking. Their subs are Fantastic .And their Pizza is top notch !!!!!!!! Hands... Down.Their pizza is always fresh and handmade .It's not greasy. And their customer service is 100%.Very nice friendly staff .If you want , great Italian food ???? , Whether its Pizza , Subs , Stromboli , or Pasta .And their prices are really fair.Youget what you pay for. Check this Italian Restaurant out.You wont be sorry., bring your appetite.Bon Appétit!!! Tim. Read more

Got a plain pizza cost 16 bucks sauce and cheese was good, crust/dough tasted like they are using pancake mix. I'll try again in... a couple months Read more

The food is always fresh,hot,delicious and the way u had asked for it. Nice and friendly staff. I drive from Lancaster city just... to order the food and enjoy the experience yummy is all I can say Read more

We had a rehearsal dinner here for our son's wedding and Louis and his family did an great job having the food ready for us. .... The pizza is amazing. He made a variety of pizzas for us. Very smooth experience for us. Read more

Bread was excellent. Roast beef was dry. Hardly any cheese. Called order in for a bus load and the order was not ready. Hot subs... weren't even heated up. Fries were cold. Vegetarian subs weren't made. People were nice. Read more

My husband and I came here for the first time ever on Tuesday and after we left we wondered what took us so long to come here.... Amazing. The food was delish ( we ordered thr philly pizza and cheesy breadsticks) and worth every penny. They have a widevariety of food options on the menu and it is all handicapped accessible and there was also a seating area outside. The insidewas very clean and quaint! Will definitely return! Read more