Reviews for Bakers Square in Schererville, IN

I've been ordering pies from Bakers Square for more than 10 years and this was the first that no one finished their slice.... Pumpkin was so dry, taste different and the crust was so dry it fell apart while cutting it. Lemon Meringue is a completelydifferent recipe and the same as pumpkin (dry), it wasn't even that pretty yellow color inside. We are completely disappointedand will never order again!! The prices went up and the quality went down drastically!!! Nov. 2022 Read more

Love the food here but management needs to train some servers on how to be friendly. Our waitress was goth looking..I say this... because I can?t remember her name.. and gave us an attitude the entire time. Made me feel like I should apologize for asking fora refill or napkins when that?s her job. Meanwhile I heard another waitress be sweet as can be to her tables. It really makes adifference for the customer. We love the food here it?s always fresh and maybe it was just an off day but please teach thisserver some manners. Read more

The BEST pies in town! Associates are very well trained and what they do, they are safety conscious and have a pleasant... demeanor towards the public! keep up the good work guys???? Read more

I haven't gone to eat there in a good while but did pick up pies three days ago. I was disappointed with the ???? cherry pie.... The filling was like a paste. It was not smooth, and the cherries were flattened. The filling was different before. Read more

Server was very attentive. She staggered my order so the soup would not arrive at the same time as my entree. Five people an... early dinner/late lunch sort of thing $95 total not to bad. Read more

Food was superb and the waitress Mackinzie was super friendly. Her suggestion of the pot roast dinner was spot on.

I just got a lemon Supreme pie. $17 my goodness. I was still looking forward to it despite the price and it was not good. The... lemon tasted like a cheap gelatin! Inflation shouldn't be ruining the quality of pie...especially when the price goes way up! Read more

We ordered a rueben and a patty melt and both were great! And their side of fruit wasn't just muskmelon or honeydew like most... places, it was strawberries and pineapple as well, so that was appreciated. Our waitress was timely and nice, too. Read more