Reviews for Amigos Cantina in Schuylerville, NY
This place could be awesome and I want it to be so badly, I love Mexican food...but there's a few things that need tweaking... before we will give it a 4th chance. For starters, the food is bland. I've had 3 different meals here now and most recently thisevening tried their Carne Asada. It was the best of the 3 meals I have had there, so that was a plus but their rice and beans(that come with most meals) literally have zero taste at all, period. I shouldn't have to douse my side dish in hot sauce inorder to make it palatable. We were seated in the bar area for our dinner, *let me warn you* it was mind numbingly loud inthere -- so much so that we could barely understand the waitress as she was giving us the specials and I couldn't hear myhusband across the (tiny) high top table. The service......our waitress was very pleasant and the gal who brought us our chipsn salsa was nice but trying to get a refill of our drinks (non-alcoholic) was laughable. We finished our drinks and waited...andwaited and waited some more. Finally when dinner came, our waitress took our glasses for refills and then we waited and waited,a good 8-10 minutes before she returned with drinks. She apologized and I'm sure it wasn't her fault but good grief, eatingdinner without a drink is no Bueno. All in all, dinner was expensive and not worth the almost $70 we paid for it. Like I saidpreviously, this was our 3rd time here--I would never leave a review based solely on one visit to an establishment but 3x andstill not impressed. Season your food, for starters..... Read more
Very popular and busy place! Good food Outside seating was all they had. Very clean and kept up well.
My wife, in-laws and I had dinner here for the first time on 8/5/2022. I ordered the Cadillac Margarita and the first one that... came out tasted like straight lime juice. I don?t normally make a fuss about a drink but if I?m paying $14 for a margarita I?dlike to taste the tequila. So I made a small comment to the waitress that it tasted like lime juice and no tequila and she saidshe would have another one made. About 10 minutes later the bartender came out and was extremely rude and condescending, tellingme she makes all the drinks the same way. She had me try the second one and it tasted much better, but she continued to be rudeand say ?Well I make them all the same way so you just had the same drink.? Well it definitely didn?t TASTE the same way. Thefood was great, the waitress was kind and attentive, and all but that one drink was good. However, due to the bartender?sterrible attitude and rudeness we will never go back. That is not the way to interact with your customers. Read more
Never disappoints. Eat-in or take-out, it's always perfect.
Delicious food! Seriously good tacos. Margaritas were fantastic. Service was fast. If we are ever in Schylerville, we would eat... here again! Read more
First time ever at this establishment. Our waitress was fantastic... That's all I can really say on the positive side. The food... was bland the cocktails were on the okay side. Sadly to me the price for food and beverage was not at all reflective. Poorlyexcuted food and overly priced for the quality. Read more
A little on the pricey side but over all it was a very good experience. The nachos and fajitas were very appetizing. The service... was great. We did not have to wait at all on a Saturday night. Will definitely go back again. Read more
First time here. So much atmosphere. Delicious food and great specials on margaritas!