Reviews for Mario's Pizzeria of Seaford in Seaford, NY
Very clean and nice interior dining atmosphere with some outdoor dining too. Delicious pizzas. The stuffed pizzas are great.... Friendly staff. Read more
It was delicious, Mario special can't go wrong.
I'm disappointed in the change from breaded zucchini sticks to battered zucchini sticks. The battered version was flavorless and... limp. It cured my obsession and I won't order them again. The Greek salad was a huge portion and tasty as usual. The tomatosauce on the eggplant was a bit salty. The meatball parm hero was good, as expected. Read more
The best pizzeria in South Nassau! They took very good care of us during the pandemic and were always cheerful. You can't go... wrong with anything you order. The whole wheat pizza is fabulous! For my birthday they sent me a coupon for a free personalizedpan pizza. It was incredible and enough for 4. The slices were heavy because they are loaded with cheese. It blows away mymemories of Pizzaria Uno. The calzones are old school Brooklyn. They are also very filling and made with good qualityingredients. The manager even called me to see how I liked the pizza. Once again, the best pizza on Long Island! Thank you,Mario's ! Read more
There are many great pizzerias on Long Island. This is not one. Ordered here by accident; I will be more careful. My pie was... somehow both undercooked AND burnt. The pepperoni wheel was really a ham and cheese roll. All pepperoni (on pie, in ?wheel?) wascold and not cooked. I could go on, but I am too sad and disappointed. Read more
I got their buffalo and Marsala slice and I am disgusted. I usually go to Umbertos or Ginos but I decided to give this place a... try. Their Marsala tasted like old gravy and was so tasteless, as you can see from the photo I could EASILY scrap off thetoppings which is so gross. I?m never coming back here again, you can not call what they?re doing here edible or even pizza. Youknow it?s bad pizza when you cant even finish a slice, and I?ve been on LI for 40 years. This was such a disappointment. Read more
Grandma's pizza was to die for, as always. You can't complete a family meal without ordering the fried dough for dessert.... Customer service was top notch. The drinks were cold and there wasn't much of a wait for fresh pizza. Would definitly recommendand can't wait to go back! Read more
The food here is great. Nice people great pernil owners are nice